Abstract:Partial association refers to the relationship between variables <math>Y1,Y2,…,YK</math> while adjusting for a set of covariates <math>X={X1,…,Xp}</math>. To assess such an association when Yk's are recorded on ordinal scales, a classical approach is to use partial correlation between the latent continuous variables. This so-called polychoric correlation is inadequate, as it requires multivariate normality and it only reflects a linear association. We propose a new framework for studying ordinal-ordinal partial association by using Liu-Zhang's surrogate residuals. We justify that conditional on <math>X</math>, Yk, and Yl are independent if and only if their corresponding surrogate residual variables are independent. Based on this result, we develop a general measure <math>ϕ</math> to quantify association strength. As opposed to polychoric correlation, <math>ϕ</math> does not rely on normality or models with the probit link, but instead it broadly applies to models with any link functions. It can capture a nonlinear or even nonmonotonic association. Moreover, the measure <math>ϕ</math> gives rise to a general procedure for testing the hypothesis of partial independence. Our framework also permits visualization tools, such as partial regression plots and three-dimensional P-P plots, to examine the association structure, which is otherwise unfeasible for ordinal data. We stress that the whole set of tools (measures, p-values, and graphics) is developed within a single unified framework, which allows a coherent inference. The analyses of the National Election Study (K = 5) and Big Five Personality Traits (K = 50) demonstrate that our framework leads to a much fuller assessment of partial association and yields deeper insights for domain researchers. <a class="ext-link" href="https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459.2020.1796394">Supplementary materials</a> for this article are available online.

Some association measures and their collapsibility

Collapsibility of distribution dependence

Qualitative Evaluation of Associations by the Transitivity of the Association Signs

Assessing Partial Association Between Ordinal Variables: Quantification, Visualization, and Hypothesis Testing

On collapsibilities of Yule’s measure

Some Results on Measures of Interaction Between Paired Risks

Partial martingale difference correlation

Distributional Overlap: Simple, Multivariate, Parametric, and Nonparametric Tests for Alienation, Convergence, and General Distributional Difference Issues

Rearranged dependence measures

Measuring Association on Topological Spaces Using Kernels and Geometric Graphs

Comment: the Essential Tension Between Parsimony and Accuracy

Distribution-free Measures of Association based on Optimal Transport

A Nonparametric Measure of Local Association for two-way Contingency Tables

Collapsibility of relative risk in contingency tables with a response variable

A New Class of Nonsymmetric Multivariate Dependence Measures

A copula-based measure for quantifying asymmetry in dependence and associations

Measuring Dependence between Events

Asymptotic expected sensitivity function and its applications to measures of monotone association

On the logic of collapsibility for causal effect measures

Strongly Consistent Multivariate Conditional Risk Measures

Measuring association with recursive rank binning