COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS ON DOWNSCALED CLIMATE SCENARIOS FOR HEADWATER CATCHMENT OF YELLOW RIVER USING SDS AND DELTA METHODS
Zhao Fangfang,Xu Zongxue
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:0577-6619.2007.04.017
2007-01-01
Acta Meteorologica Sinica
Abstract:General circulation models(GCMs) results suggest that the increasing concentration of greenhouse gases will have significant implications for climate on global and regional scales.Less confidence exists on the extent to which meteorological processes will be affected at individual site.The so-called 'downscaling' techniques are used to bridge the spatial and temporal resolution gaps between that what the climate modelers are currently able to provide and that what the impact assessors require.Strategic-scale assessments of climate change impacts are often undertaken by using the Delta method where the future climate changes projected by GCMs are applied to the baseline climatology.Alternatively,statistical downscaling(SDS) methods apply climate variables from GCMs to statistical transfer functions to estimate the point-scale meteorological series.The relative merits of the SDS and Delta methods are investigated in this paper by using a case study of scenarios in the headwater catchment of the Yellow River basin under baseline(1961-1990) and climate change conditions(2020s,2050s and 2080s).The climate change scenarios for daily precipitation and daily maximum/minimum temperature are generated by using the SDS and Delta methods,and the results show that there is a small increasing trend for the precipitation and an obvious increasing trend for the maximum/minimum daily temperature in the study periods.These departures are explained in terms of the different treatment for the multi-decadal natural variability,temporal structure of daily climate variables and large-scale forcing of local precipitation and maximum/minimum temperature by two downscaling methods.Compared with the results in the baseline for Delta scenarios,the changes of precipitation in the future are very big,it will increase 8.75%,19.70% and 18.49%,respectively;the daily maximum temperature will increase 1.41 ℃,2.42 ℃ and 3.44 ℃ in the future,and the daily minimum temperature will increase 1.49 ℃,2.68 ℃ and 3.76 ℃,respectively,which result in reduced temperature ranges in the future.For SDS scenarios modeled in virtue of observed data and NCEP reanalysis data,the changes of precipitation in the future are little,it will increase 3.47%,6.42% and 8.67% with obvious seasonal characteristics;the temperature shows obviously increasing trend,the changes are +1.34 ℃,+2.60 ℃ and +3.90 ℃ for daily maximum temperature,and +0.87 ℃,+1.49 ℃ and +2.27 ℃ for daily minimum temperature,with longer frost-free periods in the future.For the use of downscaling approaches,SDS method has more merits than Delta method,but it also has the inevitable limitation.Given the uncertainties in the GCM's ability to simulate current conditions based on either the Delta or downscaling approaches,future climate assessments based on these approaches must be treated with caution.Therefore,it is necessary to compare different techniques for the evaluation of the impact of the actual climate change,expecting to support guidance for the government.