Comparison of executive function in patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder at different ages of onset

J Yan,YF Wang,YH Cui
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1673-8225.2007.39.038
2007-01-01
Abstract:AIM: To compare executive function between different onset groups in patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), age of onset is with great span. METHODS: Totally 60 patients (40 males and 20 females) diagnosed as having OCD were enrolled from Institute of Mental Health, Peking University from November 2004 to November 2005. They were divided by 18 years old into 2 groups: first onset before 18 years group (group A) with 31 cases and first onset after 18 years group (group B) with 29 cases. All finished a series of neuropsychological tests including Wisconsin card sorting test (WCST), Trail-making test (TMT), Tower of Hanoi (TH), Rey-Osterrieth complex Figure test, Stroop test and Word fluency test (WFT). Executive functions were compared between the two groups divided by 18 years old. As follows: ①Wisconsin card sorting test was used to evaluate set-shifting. The indexes were total cards, categories, total errors, perseverative errors, cards to finish the first category. ②Trail-making test was also used to evaluate set-shifting. The indexes were performing time and errors of part A and B. ③Tower of Hanoi was used to evaluate planning. The indexes were time of movement, total time, time to start, errors and total steps. ④Rey-Osterrieth complex Figure test was used to evaluate working memory. The indexes were framework score. ⑤Stroop test was used to evaluate inhibition. The indexes were times of every part. ⑥Word fluency test was used to evaluate fluency. The indexes were total words and errors. RESULTS: A total of 60 patients were involved in the result analysis. ①Set-shifting: Patients in the group A were better than those of group B in TMT part B time (Z =-2.739, P =0.006), cards to finish the first category (Z =-2.197, P =0.028), and categories (Z =-2.030, P =0.042). ②Planning: The total time was shorter in TH in the group A than the Group B(Z =-2.107, P =0.035). ③Inhibition: Patients in the group A were better in part C time of Stroop test(Z =-2.268, P =0.009). ④No significant differences were found in working memory and fluency (Z =-0.213, P =0.831). CONCLUSION: Executive functions are found differently in different onset patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder. Patients in the early onset and late onset groups may be with 2 different kinds of OCD, and with different neurological, psychological and pathological basis.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?