Abstract:In reliability engineering, we need to understand system dependencies, cause-effect relations, identify critical components, and analyze how they trigger failures. Three prominent graph models commonly used for these purposes are fault trees (FTs), decision trees (DTs), and binary decision diagrams (BDDs). These models are popular because they are easy to interpret, serve as a communication tool between stakeholders of various backgrounds, and support decision-making processes. Moreover, these models help to understand real-world problems by computing reliability metrics, minimum cut sets, logic rules, and displaying dependencies. Nevertheless, it is unclear how these graph models compare. Thus, the goal of this paper is to understand the similarities and differences through a systematic comparison based on their (i) purpose and application, (ii) structural representation, (iii) analysis methods, (iv) construction, and (v) benefits & limitations. Furthermore, we use a running example based on a Container Seal Design to showcase the models in practice. Our results show that, given that FTs, DTs and BDDs have different purposes and application domains, they adopt different structural representations and analysis methodologies that entail a variety of benefits and limitations, the latter can be addressed via conversion methods or extensions. Specific remarks are that BDDs can be considered as a compact representation of binary DTs, since the former allows sub-node sharing, which makes BDDs more efficient at representing logical rules than binary DTs. It is possible to obtain cut sets from BDDs and DTs and construct a FT using the (con/dis)junctive normal form, although this may result in a sub-optimal FT structure.

New approach for constructing BDD from a complex fault tree

Complex Fault Tree Analysis Based on BDD Route-Based Rules

An approach to use BDD during the fault tree editing and analyzing

Analyzing Fault Tree by Using Method of Recursive BDD Technique

Basic Event Ordering in Fault Tree Analyses Using Binary Decision Diagram

A new ordering method of basic events in dynamic fault tree for sequential binary decision diagram

Quantitative analysis of dynamic fault trees using improved Sequential Binary Decision Diagrams

Efficient Fault Tree Analysis of Complex Fault Tolerant Multiple-Phased Systems

Fault Trees, Decision Trees, And Binary Decision Diagrams: A Systematic Comparison

Fault Diagnosis of Bounded Petri Nets Using Path Marking Graphs.

BFL: a Logic to Reason about Fault Trees

A BDD-Based Approach to Model Reduction of Boolean Networks

One Advanced Calculation Method for the Least Cut Set and Least Path Set of Fault Tree

An improved decomposition scheme for assessing the reliability of embedded systems by using dynamic fault trees

Depth-First Event Ordering in BDD-Based Fault Tree Analysis

Dynamic fault tree analysis based on pivotal decomposition of the structure function

BDDs Strike Back: Efficient Analysis of Static and Dynamic Fault Trees

A New Ordering Method of Basic Events in Fault Tree Analysis.

A Review on the Realization Methods of Dynamic Fault Tree

A NEW FAULT TREE ANALYSIS METHOD: FUZZY DYNAMIC FAULT TREE ANALYSIS

A New Method for the Detections of Multiple Faults Using Binary Decision Diagrams