C(94)Ipr Isomeric Set: Large-Scale Computations Of Relative Stabilities
Z Slanina,X Zhao,F Uhlik,E Osawa
2001-01-01
Abstract:At present C(94) is the highest set of isomeric fullerenes that has been characterized by (13)C NMR spectra (Achiba, Y., Miyake, Y., Ishiwatari, H., Kainosho, M. and Kikuchi, K., MRS Boston 1998 Fall Meeting, Abstract S2.2, MRS, Pittsburgh, 1998). In their further enhanced observations (T. Minami, Y. Miyake, K. Kikuchi and Y. Achiba, in The 18th Fullerene General Symposium, The Fullerene Research Association of Japan, Okazaki, 2000) four species have been recognized: C(2), C(S), C(2), and C(2). This contribution reports quantum-chemical computations on the C(94) system. The complete set of 134 isolated-pentagon-rule (IPR) isomers Of C(94) is described by four semiempirical quantum-chemical methods (MNDO, AM1, PM3, and SAM1). The C(94) energetics is also checked with Hartree-Fock SCF calculations in the standard 4-31G (HF/4-31G). The calculations point out a C(2) structure as the system ground state. As energetics itself cannot produce reliable relative stabilities at high temperatures, entropy terms are also computed and the relative-stability problem is entirely treated in terms of the Gibbs function. The lowest-energy structure remains the most populated isomer at higher temperatures. However, several other structures show significant populations at higher temperatures. The six most populated species at the AM1 computational level read: C(2), C(2), C(1), C(1), C(s), and C(2). Hence, this six-membered set of stabilomers contains the four symmetries observed in the experiment. This computational study represents another evidence that the supposed inter-isomeric thermodynamic equilibrium does exist in experiment. There may also be other interpretation, viz. that although the inter-isomeric equilibrium is not yet reached, the relative non-equilibrium and equilibrium isomeric concentrations do not differ significantly. The computational treatment of isomeric mixtures has several interesting features: The results depend on temperature but not on pressure, only the relative and not the absolute values of the heats of formation are needed, the form of the master equation allows for an ample cancellation of terms in the partition functions (in particular, the cluster mass is cancelled out exactly). The contribution also discusses a subsequent, more general task - relative stabilities of fullerenes of different dimensions, i.e., of non-isomeric fullerenes (where the mentioned cancellations do not operate).