Scale-dependent Non-Gaussianities in the WMAP Data As Identified by Using Surrogates and Scaling Indices
C. Raeth,A. J. Banday,G. Rossmanith,H. Modest,R. Suetterlin,K. M. Gorski,J. Delabrouille,G. E. Morfill
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.18844.x
IF: 4.8
2011-01-01
Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Abstract:We present a model-independent investigation of the WMAP data with respect toscale- dependent non-Gaussianities (NGs) by employing the method of constrainedrandomization. For generating so-called surrogate maps a shuffling scheme isapplied to the Fourier phases of the original data, which allows to test forthe presence of higher order correlations (HOCs) on well-defined scales. Usingscaling indices as test statistics we find highly significant signatures fornon-Gaussianities when considering all scales. We test for NGs in the bands l =[2,20], l = [20,60], l = [60,120] and l = [120,300]. We find highly significantsignatures for non-Gaussianities and ecliptic hemispherical asymmetries for l =[2, 20]. We also obtain highly significant deviations from Gaussianity for theband l = [120,300]. The result for the full l-range can be interpreted as asuperposition of the signatures found in the bands l = [2, 20] and l = [120,300]. We find remarkably similar results when analyzing different ILC-likemaps. We perform a set of tests to investigate if the detected anomalies can beexplained by systematics. While no test can convincingly rule out the intrinsicnature of the anomalies for the low l case, the ILC map making procedure and/orresidual noise in the maps can also lead to NGs at small scales. Ourinvestigations prove that there are phase correlations in the WMAP data of theCMB. In the absence of an explanation in terms of Galactic foregrounds or knownsystematic artefacts, the signatures at low l must so far be taken to becosmological at high significance. These findings strongly disagree withpredictions of isotropic cosmologies with single field slow roll inflation. Thetask is now to elucidate the origin of the phase correlations and to understandthe physical processes leading to these scale-dependent non-Gaussianities - ifsystematics as cause for them must be ruled out.