An Ethnographic Study of Product Form Perception and Usability

Shangshang Zhu,Per Boelskifte,Shijian Luo

2006-01-01

Abstract:This paper applies ethnographic methods to understand the nature of product form and the influence of usability, using experimental methods to investigate how users perceive and enjoy products, and investigate the commonalities and differences among different types of persons in perceiving product form. Instead of simply tracing users’ perception of product form, we also try to obtain data on how usability influences users’ perception of products. Selecting the media player as an example, 24 industrial design students were asked to operate the real products, reveal the deficiencies of current mode of operations, suggest improvements of the product operations reliability, and then dictate the product form they expected. 10 experienced designers were asked to design a media player for University students. Protocol analysis and design sketch were adopted to analyze the acquiring and representing of designers’ perceptual image of products’ form. The results revealed that users thought of factors related to products’ usability more than designers did, they proposed much more ideas of usage mode than designers. A 9-point Likert Scale method was then used to access designers’ and users’ preferences of 24 media player samples. Conjoint analysis method was applied to analyze the relation between preference and product form factors. Experiment results showed that there was a distinct difference between the designers and users, and it testified that the users concentrated on the product’s usability. Using ethnographic methods in human-centered product design helps designers analyze products’ usability and design new products more adapted to users. The research also gave insights that led us to a user-participant view, rather than a production perspective in design study, would be necessary for success.