Abstract:Pay for performance, as one of the most important means of motivating employees, has attracted the attention of many scholars and managers. However, controversy has continued regarding whether it promotes or undermines job performance. Drawing on a meta-analysis of 108 independent samples (N = 71,438) from 100 articles, we found that pay for performance was positively related to job performance. That pay for performance had a more substantial positive effect on task performance than contextual performance in workplace settings. From the cognitive evaluation perspective, we found that pay for performance enhanced employees' task performance and contextual performance by enhancing intrinsic motivation and weakened task performance and contextual performance by increasing employee pressure. From the equity perspective, our results indicated that the relationship between pay for performance and task performance was partially mediated by employee perceptions of distributive justice and procedural justice, with distributive justice having a more substantial mediating effect than procedural justice. However, the relationship between pay for performance and contextual performance was only partially mediated by procedural justice. Further tests of moderating effects indicated that the varying impacts of pay for performance are contingent on measures of pay for performance and national culture. The findings contributed to understanding the complex mechanisms and boundary conditions of pay-for-performance's effects on job performance, which provided insights for organizations to maximize its positive effects.

Employee Job Performance: An Exchange View

A Review of Theories on the Relationship between the Constructs of Task Performance and Non-Task Performance

Model of development and empirical study on employee job performance construct

Task Performance and Contextual Performance Based on Performance Separability

Leader-Member Exchange and Employee Job Performance: Review and Prospect

Employee Experienced Hpwps and Job Performance: Roles of Person-Job Fit and Intrinsic Motivation

High‐performance work system and employee performance: the mediating roles of social exchange and thriving and the moderating effect of employee proactive personality

Leader-Member Exchange, Efficacy and Job Performance: A Cognitive Perspective Interpretation

How and when Does Service Performance Improve Positive Emotions? an Employee–customer Social Exchange Perspective

Research On Performance Evaluation Mechanism Of Employees In Real Estate Enterprise Based On Psychological Contract

On the Study of Performance Evaluation

The Moderating Effect of Job Characteristics on the Relationship between Person-Organization Fit and Employees' Performance

A Cognitive Evaluation and Equity-Based Perspective of Pay for Performance on Job Performance: A Meta-Analysis and Path Model

A Performance Analysis Model for Corporate Human Resource Management Based on Extenics Theory

The Comparison and Integration Analysis of STRATEGIC Performance Management Assessment Tool

Study on Employee Performance Measurement Based on Different Organizational Forms

Performance Feedback and Organizational Responses: A Literature Review and Prospects

The Impact of Transactional and Relational Psychological Contract on Employees’ Task and Contextual Performance:The Moderating Roles of Pay for Performance and Perceived Supervisor Support

The Relationship between Performance Appraisal and Worker Counter-ethical Behaviors: Literature Review and Future Perspective

Corporate Blogging and Job Performance: Effects of Work-related and Nonwork-related Participation.

The Research on The Relationship Between Employee Psychology and Work Performance