Comparative Toxicity Analyses from Different Endpoints: Are New Cyclic Disinfection Byproducts (DBPs) More Toxic than Common Aliphatic DBPs?
Yun Wu,Wenzhe Wei,Jiayi Luo,Yang Pan,Mengting Yang,Ming Hua,Wenhai Chu,Chendong Shuang,Aimin Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.1c03292
2021-12-22
Abstract:In recent years, dozens of halogenated disinfection byproducts (DBPs) with cyclic structures were identified and detected in drinking water globally. Previous <i>in vivo</i> toxicity studies have shown that a few new cyclic DBPs possessed higher developmental toxicity and growth inhibition rate than common aliphatic DBPs; however, <i>in vitro</i> toxicity studies have proved that the latter exhibited higher cytotoxicity and genotoxicity than the former. Thus, to provide a more comprehensive toxicity comparison of DBPs from different endpoints, 11 groups of cyclic DBPs and nine groups of aliphatic DBPs were evaluated for their comparative <i>in vitro</i> and <i>in vivo</i> toxicity using human hepatoma cells (Hep G2) and zebrafish embryos. Notably, results showed that the <i>in vitro</i> Hep G2 cytotoxicity index of the aliphatic DBPs was nearly eight times higher than that of the cyclic DBPs, whereas the <i>in vivo</i> zebrafish embryo developmental/acute toxicity indexes of the cyclic DBPs were roughly 48-50 times higher than those of the aliphatic DBPs, indicating that the toxicity rank order differed when different endpoints were applied. For a broader comparison, a Pearson correlation analysis of DBP toxicity data from nine different endpoints was conducted. It was found that the observed Hep G2 cytotoxicity and zebrafish embryo developmental/acute toxicity in this study were highly correlated with the previously reported <i>in vitro</i> CHO cytotoxicity and <i>in vivo</i> toxicity in aquatic organisms (<i>P</i> < 0.01), respectively. However, the observed <i>in vitro</i> toxicity had no correlation with the <i>in vivo</i> toxicity (<i>P</i> > 0.05), suggesting that the toxicity rank orders obtained from <i>in vitro</i> and <i>in vivo</i> bioassays had large discrepancies. According to the observed toxicity data in this study and the candidate descriptors, two quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) models were established, which help to further interpret the toxicity mechanisms of DBPs from different endpoints.
environmental sciences,engineering, environmental