Comparison Between Methods for Power System Nonlinear Modal Analysis
Fu-xia WU,Hao WU,Zhen-xiang HAN,De-qiang GAN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:0258-8013.2007.34.004
2007-01-01
Abstract:Two methods for power system nonlinear modal analysis, i.e., modal series method and normal form method, are compared. Two types of second-order participation factors of modal series method are proposed and qualitatively compared with that of normal form method. A nonlinearity index for normal form method is defined based on the original index, and its validity is verified by the case studies in two-area four-generator power system. To evaluate the precision of solutions obtained by modal series method, normal form method and linear modal method, an error index describing the approximation to the nonlinear simulation is defined and then applied to the same system, It is found that the validity of modal series method and linear modal method is not influenced by the second-order resonance condition, which has a great influence on normal form method. When the operating condition is near the second-order resonance condition, the valid area of normal form method is quite small. The degree of system stress can be increased by changing the fault duration. It is found that as the system stress increases, the error index and its growing speed of modal series method are the smallest, and that of normal form method take second place.