Abstract:Stochastic subspace identification (SSI) and Bayesian methods are now the main representative approaches for high-performance system identification and uncertainty quantification. Both methods have been extensively used in engineering applications for the last 10 years despite them having quite different views in principle. However, no comparison has been carried out to inform which method is actually better for engineering applications in terms of modal identification accuracy, uncertainty quantification, and so forth. This paper therefore investigates the differences between these two quantifications of parameter uncertainty in system identification. Synthetic data for a six-degree-of-freedom spring-mass numerical system are first studied to compare their identification accuracy and applicable conditions. The investigation is then extended to field data from actual structures, which involves ambient modal testing of Heritage Court Tower in Canada, Canton Tower in China, and Ting Kau Bridge in Hong Kong. Results from the synthetic data show that, under white-noise excitation, identified modal parameters and quantified uncertainty for both methods are highly consistent with the values of frequentist statistics. However, when the excitation is not white noise, there may be some spurious modes identified via SSI, and the uncertainty quantified under colored-noise excitation via SSI is almost always larger than those under white noise, while the Bayesian method is not disturbed. Results for the structural field data indicate that in general applications under environmental excitation the identified modal parameters from both methods are almost identical; the quantified uncertainty of the SSI method is slightly larger than that of the Bayesian method, but they are of the same order of magnitude and can meet engineering requirements.

Structural Singular Value (μ) Analysis of Uncertainty of Flexible Structures

Continuous sliding mode control for uncertain linear time-invariant systems with matched and unmatched uncertainties using the Lyapunov-function integral sliding mode

Variable Structure Control for a Class of Systems with Mismatched Uncertainties

H∞-based structural robustness analysis

Robust Variable Structure Control for Uncertain Interconnected Systems Based on LMIs Approach

Analysis of structural robustness with non-probabilistic uncertainties

Robustness of nonlinear stochastic optimal control for uncertain structures

A STOCHASTIC EQUIVALENT LINEARIZATION FOR ANALYSIS OF MULTIPLE-DEGREE-OF-FREEDOM FLEXIBLE STRUCTURES

Application of QMU to Structural Analysis Considering Uncertainty

Finite Element Modeling and Validating of Structural Uncertainty Factors

Feedback Control and Modal Analysis of Structures with Uncertainties

Nonlinear Random Vibration of Multiple-Degree-of-freedom Flexible Structures

Sliding mode control of structural vibration with unmatched uncertainties

LFT-Structured Uncertainty State-Space Modeling for State Feedback Robust Control of the Ultra-Precision Wafer Stage

Vibration Control and Its Perturbation Analysis of Intelligent Structures with Uncertainties

On the Robust Stability Analysis with Real Block Structured Uncertainties.

Feedback Control of Intelligent Structures with Uncertainties and Its Robustness Analysis

Engineering Performance of Two Analytical Methodologies for Estimating Modal Parameter Uncertainty for Structures

The Mixed-Uncertainty Modeling and Control for Active Suspension Based on Robust Μ-Synthesis

Mixed uncertainty analysis for dynamic reliability of mechanical structures considering residual strength

Robust Stability of Linear Time-Invariant Systems with Hybrid Uncertainties