Comparison of serum creatinine,Cystatin C and estimated glomerular filtration rate on evaluation of glomerular filtration function in chronic kidney disease patients
WANG Xue-jing,XU Guo-bin,LI Hai-xia,LI Shu-kui,ZHAO Jin-rong,XIA Tie-an,王学晶,徐国宾,李海霞,李淑葵,赵进荣,夏铁安
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/J.ISSN:1009-9158.2007.04.015
2007-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the coherence of serum creatinine,creatinine clearance(Ccr), Cystatin C,and estimated glomerular filtration rate(eGFR)in each stage of chronic kidney disease(CKD) patients.Methods Creatinine in serum and urine were determined by Jaffe method;serum Cystatin C was measured by particle enhanced turbidimetric method,while eGFR was calculated using the abbreviated Modification of Diet in Renal Disease(MDRD)equation which was mainly based on the serum creatinine concentration.According to the American national kidney foundation-Kidney Disease Outcome Quality Initiative(NKF-K/DOQI)guideline,all cases were grouped by eGFR into 5 stages.Results In these 228 cases,as eGFR decreased gradually,the average levels of creatinine and Cystatin C increased,while Ccr decreased.The level of each items showed a statistic difference among each stage(P<0.05);in eGFR≤ 29 ml/min groups,the abnormal rates of Scr,Ccr and Cystatin C were all 100 %,and the average levels of Scr and Cystatin C were 4-6 times and 3.5-5.5 times to the upper reference limit,while Ccr was 3.8-7.3 times to the lower reference limit;in eGFR 30-59 ml/min group,the average levels of creatinine,Ccr and Cystatin C were 129.2 μmol/L,44.3 ml/min and 2.16 mg/L,and the abnormal rate were 84%,91% and 98% respectively,no statistic difference was observed among the three rates(P>0.05);in eGFR 60-89 ml/min group,the average level of creatinine was 83.3 μmol/L,the abnormal rate was only 6.8%,it was not a sensitive marker to detect the slightly damaged GFR,the levels of Ccr and Cystatin C showed a marginal decrease and increase,with an abnormal rates of 70% and 86%,there was a statistic difference among the three abnormal rates(P<0.05);when eGFR≥90 ml/min,the abnormal rate of creatinine was 0,while the abnormal rates of Ccr and Cystatin C still highly reached to 44% and 59%, respectively.Conclusions when eGFR<60 ml/min,it showed a good coherence with Scr,Ccr and Cystatin C,at this time,a conclusion could be drown that glomeruler filtration function had decreased moderately; when 60 ml/min≤eGFR≤89 ml/min,Scr could not reflect the damage on GFR,but Cystatin C and Ccr could at least select out 2/3 patients with abnormal GFR,and Cystatin C was more sensitive than Ccr;when eGFR≥90 ml/min,MDRD equation overestimated the real GFR,so it was not fit for patients with a normal Scr level,especially to the elder CKD patients,for these patients,it was requested to check Ccr and Cystatin C to find out GFR damage timely.