The characteristics of particulate size and heavy metal concentration in foliar dust and surface dust among different urban areas in Guangzhou, China
Lu Liu,Dongsheng Guan,Yangfan Yu,Gang Wang,Mervyn Richard Peart
2012-01-01
Fresenius environmental bulletin
Abstract:Dust samples were collected from 6 sites characterizing 4 different types of urban area, namely, Industrial (IA), Residential (RA), Commercial with vehicular traffic (CTA), along with a University campus (CA), in Guangzhou, China. The particulate size characteristics and heavy metal concentrations (Cr, Cd, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn) of the samples were determined by Laser Particle Size Analysis and ICP-AES, respectively. The enrichment factor (EF) was used to evaluate the cumulative status of the pollutants among different types of urban area, and possible sources of these heavy metals were identified by principal component analysis (PCA) and correlation coefficient analysis. The results revealed that particle size distributions in dusts (foliar and surface dust) among different urban areas were reasonably similar, and that the particle size distributions of foliar dust and surface dust were mainly concentrated on 10 to 50 mu m fractions (46 to 59.1%). However, the proportion of PM2.5 and PM10 in foliar dust (22.35 and 26.12%) was larger than that in surface dust (15.46 and 20.3%). The concentration of heavy metals was significantly different (P< 0.05) among the various urban areas, and, in particular, the contaminations in the IA and CTA areas were relatively serious. In general, Cr, Pb, Cd and Cu exhibited the highest mean concentrations in foliar dust. For Mn and Zn, in 3 out of the 4 urban type areas, the highest mean concentrations were observed in the surface dust of buildings. Three groups of metals can be identified using the EF; firstly, Cd with very high EF values ranging from 47.75-84.28; secondly, Mn, Cr and Ni for which the EF is generally <10; and finally, Pb, Cu and Zn which are intermediate between the two end members. Correlation coefficients have been determined and revealed that the elemental pairs Cu-f-Cu-s, Mn-f-Mn-s, Zn-f-Zn-s, and Pb-f-Pb-s exhibited significant positive correlations. Regarding the correlation of metals within the foliar and surface dust samples, for both types of dust, Ni generally exhibited a negative association with other metals. The EF, PCA and correlation coefficient analyses were used to make inferences regarding metal sources. The EF data suggest that Ni, and to a lesser extent, Cr, mainly originated from local soil and were not greatly impacted by human activities. For the other metals, enhancement in the IA reflected the location of a steelworks and a shipyard in the sampling areas. The analysis also suggests. that vehicular traffic is an important source. However, other potential sources including building decay/ weathering, waste burning and incineration, fossil fuel combustion etc exist within Guangzhou. The foliar dust samples collected from the trees attested to the ability of vegetation to improve air quality whilst the presence of elevated concentrations of dust in samples from building surfaces have implications for urban environmental quality and its monitoring.