A Coordination Model of Two-Suppliers and One-Manufacturer under Uncertain Delivery
LI Guo,MA Shi-hua,GAO Tao,WANG Zhao-hua
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-6062.2011.03.016
2011-01-01
Abstract:Uncertainties in supply,manufacturing or customer demand can disrupt supply chain operations.However,supply chain disruption caused by manufacturing and demand uncertainties have not been extensively studied in the current literature.The increase of social and natural disasters,such as 9/11 terrorist attack in the USA and earthquake in Japan,are raising the importance of studying supply chain uncertainty and disruption. This study focuses on random yields as an important aspect of supply uncertainty.In the multi-suppliers and one-manufacturer system with random yields and JIT delivery,each supplier will optimize its production quantity according to manufacturer's order quantity.The quantity delivered by different suppliers may be mismatched due to random yields.Delivery quantity of suppliers can lead to mismatching of component quantity in an assembly system.As a result of the mismatching issue,overstock and out-of-stock problems in stores can occur frequently.Therefore,it is essential to design an effective strategy to streamline the operation of multi-suppliers and one-manufacturer system. We construct a mathematical model for the two-supplier and one-manufacturer coordination based on penalty policy under delivery uncertainty.The model is to address the following questions:(1) How will residual value influence the decision of a manufacturer if order quantity is larger than delivery quantity?(2) How will inventory costs influence the decision of manufacturer and supplier due to uncertain delivery quantity of suppliers? and(3) How to use penalty cost to influence the supply chain coordination? The model is constructed based on the assumptions of risk neutral,information symmetry,fully rational decision makers,assembly of proportional parts,and JIT delivery. Our findings show that the expected profit function of suppliers is the concave function of production quantity.There is only one best production quantity to maximize the expected profit of suppliers.Given the order quantity of a manufacturer,there exists a unique Nash equilibrium between two suppliers' game in the decentralized decision mode.If order quantity,purchase price,inventory cost and unit production cost are predetermined,the unit penalty cost can indirectly influence the optimal expected profit function of suppliers.The expected profit function of manufacturers is a concave function of order quantity and there exists only one best order quantity to maximize the expected profit of suppliers.Furthermore,a manufacturer's optimal order quantity is larger than or equal to the market demand. In summary,under the condition of delivery uncertainty caused by random yields of suppliers the two-supplier and one-manufacturer system can adopt our proposed penalty mechanism to coordinate supply chain operations.The mechanism ensures that a manufacturer can adjust the order quantity and unit component penalty cost to maximize the profit for the entire supply chain.