Environmental benefit analysis of “road-to-rail” policy in China based on a railway tunnel measurement
Hui Tong,Jianfei Peng,Yanjie Zhang,Tiange Fang,Jinsheng Zhang,Zhengyu Men,Yan Liu,Lin Wu,Ting Wang,Fumin Ren,Honglei Xu,Weichao Wang,Zhuofei Du,Hongjun Mao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.128227
IF: 11.1
2021-09-01
Journal of Cleaner Production
Abstract:<p>The substitution of long-distance road transportation by railways, so-called the "road-to-rail" policy, is one of the major national regulatory policies for atmospheric pollution mitigation in China. However, owing to the lack of real-world diesel locomotive emission measurements, the environmental benefits of the "road-to-rail" policy have not been well evaluated. In this study, emissions from 245 in-use line-haul diesel locomotives (including three types of DF4, HX3, and HX5) were measured under real-world conditions via a railway tunnel observation conducted in Beijing on September 7–13, 2017. The fuel-specific and distance-specific emission factors (EFs) of NOx, CO, SO<sub>2</sub>, and BC were determined by using the carbon balance and mass conservation methods, respectively. The measured EFs of NOx and CO for the HX series locomotives were 41% and 30% higher than the Tire 2 emission standard limits respectively. Based on the two sets of EFs and corresponding activity levels, total locomotive emissions of NOx and CO in China in 2018 were approximately 17.36–19.23 × 10<sup>4</sup> t and 4.76–5.69 × 10<sup>4</sup> t respectively. Scenario analysis based on the fuel life cycle shows that all "road-to-rail" scenarios reduce the total energy consumption and pollutant emissions in the short term. For the scenario maintaining the current proportion (20%) of diesel locomotives, the "road-to-rail" policy may reduce NOx and BC emissions by 7.03–70.33 × 10<sup>4</sup> t/year and 0.10–1.02 × 10<sup>4</sup> t/year respectively. Considering the upgradation of emission standards with heavy-duty diesel vehicles, the air quality improvement benefit of the "road-to-rail" policy may only be sustained for 2–3 years and 8 years respectively, under the full diesel locomotive scenario and the current diesel locomotive scenario. We highlight the necessity of a more careful and accurate estimation of "road-to-rail" policy environmental benefits to obtain better air quality and the greatest health benefits.</p>
environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology,engineering, environmental