Abstract:Nonadiabatic quantum-classical mapping approaches have significantly gained in popularity in the past several decades because they have acceptable accuracy while remaining numerically tractable even for large system sizes. In the recent few years, several novel mapping approaches have been developed that display higher accuracy than the traditional Ehrenfest method, linearized semiclassical initial value representation (LSC-IVR), and Poisson bracket mapping equation (PBME) approaches. While various benchmarks have already demonstrated the advantages and limitations of those methods, rigorous theoretical justifications of their short-time accuracy are still demanded. In this article, we systematically examine the intra-electron correlation, as a statistical measure of electronic phase space, which has been first formally proposed for mapping approaches in the context of the generalized discrete truncated Wigner approximation (GDTWA) and which is a key ingredient for the improvement of short-time accuracy of such mapping approaches. We rigorously establish the connection between short-time accuracy and intra-electron correlation for various widely used models. We find that LSC-IVR, PBME, and Ehrenfest methods fail to correctly reproduce the intra-electron correlation. While some of the traceless Meyer--Miller--Stock--Thoss (MMST) approaches, partially linearized density matrix (PLDM) approach, and spin partially linearized density matrix (Spin-PLDM) approach are able to sample the intra-electron correlation correctly, the spin linearized semiclassical (Spin-LSC) approach and the other traceless MMST approaches sample the intra-correlation faithfully only for two-level systems. Our theoretical analysis provides insights into the short-time accuracy of semiclassical methods and presents mathematical justifications for previous numerical benchmarks.

Communication: importance sampling including path correlation in semiclassical initial value representation calculations for time correlation functions.

Real Time Correlation Function in a Single Phase Space Integral--beyond the Linearized Semiclassical Initial Value Representation

Correlation Functions in Open Quantum-Classical Systems

Accessing the bath information in open quantum systems with the stochastic c-number Langevin equation method.

Recent Advances in the Linearized Semiclassical Initial Value Representation/classical Wigner Model for the Thermal Correlation Function

Nonadiabatic Dynamics Via the Symmetrical Quasi-Classical Method in the Presence of Anharmonicity.

Intramolecular vibrational energy redistribution as state space diffusion: Classical-quantum correspondence

Time correlation functions for quantum systems: validating Bayesian approaches for harmonic oscillators and beyond

Semiclassical Vibrational Spectroscopy of Real Molecular Systems by Means of Cross-Correlation Filter Diagonalization

Short-time Accuracy and Intra-electron Correlation for Nonadiabatic Quantum-Classical Mapping Approaches

Extended Coupled-States Approximation for Full-Dimensional Quantum Treatments of Rovibrationally Inelastic Scattering Between Atoms and Triatomic Molecules

Novel Molecular-Dynamics-Based Protocols for Phase Space Sampling in Complex Systems

Semiclassical dynamics in the mixed quantum-classical limit

Linearized Semiclassical Initial Value Time Correlation Functions Using the Thermal Gaussian Approximation: Applications to Condensed Phase Systems.

Efficient Time-Sampling Method in Coulomb-corrected Strong-Field Approximation

Observing Intramolecular Vibrational Energy Redistribution Via the Short-Time Fourier Transform

Anharmonic Vibrational States of Solids from DFT Calculations. Part II: Implementation of the VSCF and VCI Methods

Test of the Consistency of Various Linearized Semiclassical Initial Value Time Correlation Functions in Application to Inelastic Neutron Scattering from Liquid Para-Hydrogen

Towards a correct description of initial electronic coherence in nonadiabatic dynamics simulations

Importance-sampling computation of statistical properties of coupled oscillators

Advanced momentum sampling and Maslov phases for a precise semiclassical model of strong-field ionization