The Effect of Counter-balance towards the Largest Shareholder on the Amount of Related Party Transactions and the Consistence of Related Party Sales
Hong Jianqiao,Xue Hao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2008.01.004
2008-01-01
Abstract:Focusing on four kinds of frequently occurred related party transactions, which include related party sales, related party purchase, offering service to and receiving service from related party, this paper examines two influence of counter-balance towards the largest shareholder, an important measurement of corporate gover- nance, on such related party transactions. First, the effect of counter- balance towards the largest shareholder on the amount of related party transactions. Second, the effect of counter-balance on the consistence of related party sales. Basing on the largest 10 shareholders and con- certed action people information disclosed by Chinese listed A-share manufacturing companies in annual report from 2002 to 2004, we adjust to get the largest 2 shareholder groups, compute their holding percentage, and then define companies whose adjusted second largest shareholder group owns more than specific percent shares as compa- nies with counter-balance towards the largest shareholder. The evi- dence indicates that the companies with counter-balance towards the largest shareholder tend to have smaller amount of related party trans- actions, not only in absolute amount but also in relative amount that is defined as absolute amount divided by beginning total assets. Besides, using the related party transaction details disclosed in the appendix of annual report, the paper distinguishes the related party transactions traded with the largest shareholder group from the transactions traded with other related parties. The evidence finds out that the restriction effect of counter-balance on the amount of related party transactions is caused only by the decrease of transactions traded with the larg- est shareholder group, but not influenced by transactions traded with other related parties. Finally, this paper divides company’s sales into two parts: sales with related parties and with non-related parties, and examines the effect of counter-balance on the consistence of both parts. The results indicate that counter-balance towards the largest shareholder tends to improve the consistence of related party sales: the related party sales occurred in the company with counter-balance are more consistent.