Wives' Relative Income and Marital Quality in Urban China: Gender Role Attitudes as a Moderator 1
Huiping Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3138/jcfs.46.2.203
2015-01-01
Journal of Comparative Family Studies
Abstract:INTRODUCTIONThe participation of married women in the labor market has been one of the most dramatic demographic changes to contemporary urban Chinese family (Edwige and Jin, 2005). The employment of married women has led to greater economic contributions to their families, both in absolute terms and relative to their husbandsu0027 incomes. The emerging trend of women as the secondary, or even the primary breadwinner in contemporary urban China has aroused wide interest (Yangcheng Evening News, 2009). Wives with an income advantage have easily grabbed the audiencesu0027 attentions, not only due to natural curiosity regarding such situations, but also arising from the uneasiness toward the impact of contemporary womenu0027s independent incomes on marital relationships (Tichenor, 2005).The impact of womenu0027s income on marital outcomes has been studied intensively in the west and relevant studies in Chinese societies are also emerging recently (Zhang, Tsang, Chi, Cheung, Zhang, u0026 Yip, 2012). One mainstream line of study supported the economic independence model, that is, wivesu0027 income is positively associated with the risk of divorce (Heckert et ah, 1998; Kalmijn et ah, 2007; Rogers and Deboer, 2001). However, another line of study suggested that wivesu0027 income would add capital and assets to the marriage and enhance the quality of life for the family. This addition would presumably render the marriage more attractive to the couple and thus lower the risk of marital dissolution (Oppenheimer, 1997; Say er and Bianchi, 2000). So, studies testing for the presence of an independence effect or an income effect have been generally inconclusive. Mixed empirical results suggest that the models of the income effect or of the independence effect may not be comprehensive enough, so it is necessary to focus on new variables that might moderate the relation between wivesu0027 relative income and marital quality (Lobl, 2006; Sayer and Bianchi, 2000).One of the most frequently studied moderators was gender role attitudes in previous studies (Greenstein, 1996; Hohmann-Marriott, 2006; Lavee and Katz, 2002). In reality, different couples may hold different cultural value orientation towards gender roles. Therefore, it is plausible to argue that the evaluations of the wivesu0027 income advantage in marriage are different for couples with a traditional gender role orientation from those with an egalitarian gender role orientation. With the fast socioeconomic development and modernization of contemporary China, the general status of women inside and outside home has undergone rapid transformation. Womenu0027s education once fell far behind that of men in the early years of the PRC, however, womenu0027s educational attainment has gradually caught up with that of men after the reform era (Hannum and Xie, 1994; Li and Xie, 2013; Wu and Zhang, 2010). Womenu0027s universal employment has been ensured since the founding of the PRC, although severe occupation segregation has persisted for non-agricultural jobs over time (Wu and Wu, 2008) and gender gap in earnings has also gradually increased (Hauser and Xie, 2005). All these economic and socio-political policies in urban China might lead women to endorse egalitarian attitudes toward gender roles at home.One recent study conducted in Taiwan and Shanghai showed that marital power was positively associated with egalitarian gender role attitudes as well as with the wifeu0027s higher income (Chien and Yi, 2014), however, the link between the wifeu0027 relative income and gender role attitudes with marital quality remains unclear in the Chinese community. Therefore, the purpose of the present study is to examine the potential role of gender role attitudes in the association between wivesu0027 relative income and marital quality in urban China.Wivesu0027 Relative Income and Marital Quality: Resource Exchange TheoryA nationwide household survey on the social status of urban Chinese women in 2000 showed that the proportions of families in which the wivesu0027 income relative to family income was less than 50%, equal to 50%, and more than 50% were, 64%, 15% and 21% respectively, based on the report from 4602 women and were 72%, 12% and 16%, respectively, based on the report from 3715 men (Shu et al. …