Is Competitive Contracting Really Competitive? Exploring Governmentnonprofit Collaboration In China

Yijia Jing,Bin Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10967494.2012.761054
IF: 2.6
2012-01-01
International Public Management Journal
Abstract:Local governments in China have adopted competitive contracting in social service delivery to restructure burgeoning governmentnonprofit collaborations. The stated purpose of using competitive contracting is to forge formal, effective, and accountable collaborative relations. By applying institutional, transaction cost, and resource dependence theories to China's context, we reveal the institutional pressures of adopting a competitive contracting policy and identify the challenges of economizing transaction costs and handling mutual resource dependence in its implementation. We find the prevalence of decoupling to meet these competing pressures at the sacrifice of competition: that is, many contracts only appear competitive. We conducted interviews, participant observations, and a questionnaire survey to study a large-scale, social-service-contracting program in Shanghai. The results provide evidence of weak competition. Local governments in Shanghai were not able to effectively coordinate competitive bidding and thus strategically kept a decentralized implementation and management system based on existing relations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?