Competency Model Development and Validation for University Faculty
Niu Duan,Zhang Minqiang
2012-01-01
Abstract:The purpose of this research was to develop and validate a competency model for university faculty.First,the competency model for university faculty was developed through integrating Behavioral Event Interview(BEI) with O*NET job analysis.Using O*NET job analysis tools,the authors investigated 405 college teachers in another study and built the preliminary competency code dictionary(including 31 competencies).Following the classical BEI method,this study interviewed 24 college teachers(15 outstanding teachers and 9 ordinary ones).According to the code dictionary mentioned above,210,000 Chinese characters were clarified and coded by two Ph.D.candidates in psychometrics.Then,this study did the comparison of the average competency ranks of college teachers with different performances by the test with SPSS 16.0.The competency model(narrow-sense competency model) for college faculty included eight competencies:creativity,critical thinking,teaching strategies,concentration,social service orientation,analytical thinking,achievement,and respect for others,among which the former four competencies were significant at.05 level,whereas the latter four were significant at.10 level.Second,to validate the expert validity of the competency model,this study interviewed five subject matter experts(SMEs).Through focus group interviews(FGI),the experts agreed that the significant level should be set at the.10 level,which would be more in line with the reality.The experts also considered other competencies such as reflection,active learning,students care,team leadership,as important competencies for college faculty.So when the "self-evaluated competency questionnaire for university faculty" was constructed and the construct validity of the scale was validated,both the differentiating competencies and the threshold competencies were included in the scale.796 college teachers took part in the survey,half of the data were randomly selected for the exploratory factor analysis and the other half for confirmatory factor analysis.The results indicated that the scale(same as the generalized competency model) could be reduced into three factors as creativity orientation,achievement orientation,and people orientation.The coefficient for the three factors were.89,.91,and.86,respectively.The confirmatory factor analysis confirmed the three-factor model.Furthermore,to validate the concurrent construct validity of the competency model,this research sampled eight colleges and obtained 183 teachers' performance level and competency level scores from their supervisors' evaluation.The results confirmed that outstanding teachers received higher competency level scores than ordinary teachers,who received higher competency level scores than inferior teachers.This research indicated that it was feasible to integrate structured job analysis with BEI when developing competency model and the questionnaire constructed had good reliability and validity which could be used for faculty competency evaluation.