Civil Service Reform in China: An Unfinished Task of Value Balancing

Yijia Jing,Qianwei Zhu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0734371X12438243
2012-01-01
Review of Public Personnel Administration
Abstract:Despite a consistent task to balance political, managerial, and legal values, China's civil service reform in the past three decades demonstrated a paradigmatic shift from a conflict-oriented to harmony-oriented model. The 2005 Civil Service Law highlighted a legal effort to institutionalize the coexistence of competing values. Such a shift was justified by, besides the changed path of political reform, contextual factors including the convergence of values, the strategy of decoupling, and the validated advantages of a unified system. An examination of the post-2005 developments discloses complex patterns of interaction between values across reform arenas, showing a limit to the harmony-oriented model. Despite its capability to constrain outright conflicts, China's integrated political system faces an urgent demand of institutional capacities to balance the competing values.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?