Narrow-Band Imaging and White-Light Endoscopy with Optical Magnification in the Diagnosis of Dysplasia in Barrett'S Esophagus: Results of the Asia-Pacific Barrett'S Consortium
Rajvinder Singh,Mahesh Jayanna,Jennie Wong,Xia Zhang,Jing Lv,Ming-Lan Han,Vikneswaran Namasivayam,Noriya Uedo,Wah Keong Chan,Chi-Yang Chang,Rupa Banerjee,Dong Liu,Shi-Yao Chen,Shobna Bhatia,Kohei Funasaka,William Tam,Kee Wook Jung,Cosmas R. Lesmana,Wen-Lun Wang,Lee Guan Lim,Hwoon-Yong Jung,Kenshi Yao,Shiaw-Hooi Ho,Prateek Sharma,Khek-Yu Ho
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0034-1377610
2014-01-01
Endoscopy International Open
Abstract:Objective: The advent and utility of new endoscopic imaging modalities for predicting the histology of Barrett's esophagus (BE) in real time with high accuracy appear promising and could potentially obviate the need to perform random biopsies where guidelines are poorly adhered to. We embarked on evaluating the performance characteristics of white-light endoscopy with magnification (WLE-z), narrow-band imaging with magnification (NBI-z) and a combination of both modalities.Design: This was a prospective online study with 28 endoscopists from 11 countries (Asia-Pacific region) participating as assessors. In total, 35 patients with BE were assessed using 150 slides from WLE-z and NBI-z randomly arranged using a simple classification with corresponding histology. The overall Accuracy (Acc), Sensitivity (Sn), Specificity (Sp), Positive Predictive Value (PPV), and Negative Predictive Value (NPV) of WLE-z, NBI-z and a combination of both were calculated.Results: The overall Acc for WLE-z and NBI-z images was 87.1% and 88.7 %, respectively. When images from the two modalities were placed side by side, the Acc increased to 90.3 %. The Sn, Sp, PPV, and NPV of WLE-z were 48%, 92%, 45%, and 93% while with NBI-z, these improved to 89%, 89 %, 56%, and 98%, respectively. When both imaging modalities were viewed together, they improved further to 93%, 90%, 61%, and 99%.Conclusion: The high NPV (99 %) when both WLE-z and NBI-z were used simultaneously indicates that areas with regular appearance that are diagnosed with confidence can effectively be left alone and not biopsied when performed at a skilled resourced center. This approach could potentially lead to a paradigm shift of how patients with BE are assessed.