Technical Comment
Johannes U. Ammann,Martin Jahnke,M. Dyson,J. Kaufman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/003754976901200608
1969-06-01
Abstract:Dimeric IgG1 Fc tail-based fusion proteins are popular reagents in immunology. They are used for receptor activation, by mimicking ligands, and for measuring binding of proteins to receptors on cells. Using IgG fusion proteins, only those interactions with dissociation constants in the μM range or lower appear to be detected. Multimeric molecules, such as trimers, tetramers, and pentamers, have increased avidity but can be difficult to prepare and may have limited flexibility [1,2]. Multimerization of IgG fusion proteins using fluorescent beads can further increase avidity but in some applications, involving centrifugation for example, beads had in our hands a tendency to dissociate from cells in case of very weak interactions (unpublished observations). In searching for a highly multimeric and flexible reagent for flow cytometry and immunoassays, we developed IgMbased fusion proteins [3,4]. IgM molecules may form “crab-like” or “table-like” structures when they bind antigen [5]. The antigen-binding domains act as “legs” and the rest of the molecule acts as a flexible structure connecting these antigenbound sections. The adaptability of this structure may be due to the length of the heavy chain, which spans five immunoglobulin domains, whereas IgG encompasses four [6]. In principle each IgM multimer can have up to twelve antigenbinding sites whereas IgG molecules have only two. A further advantage of IgM over IgG molecules is that they are suitable for probing cells expressing IgG Fc receptors such as professional antigen presenting cells or NK cells. We coupled the extracellular domains of proteins to Ig domains 3–5 of the human IgM heavy chain. Domains 4 and 5 of the human IgM heavy chain contain cysteine residues that form disulfide bonds, required for the formation of multimers [7,8]. The immunoglobulin IgG1 Fc tail monomer has two cysteine residues whereas the immunoglobulin IgM heavy chain has three. A 15 kDa molecule called the J-chain (joining-chain) is associated with IgA or IgM molecules. It contains eight cysteine residues that form disulfide bonds with cysteine residues in the IgM heavy chain [9]. Despite the fact that IgM molecules are secreted without the J-chain [10], it is important for formation of higher multimerized IgM molecules [11], and is required for trans-mucosal transport [12]. The number of J-chain molecules increases with the number of IgM heavy chains contained in a multimer [13]. However, the number of J-chain molecules per IgM polymer and the stoichiometry of the complexes is debated. We assessed by flow cytometry and immunoassay whether co-expression of the J-chain influences binding of IgM-based heavy chain fusions to antigen. We also compared the binding of IgG-based and IgM-based fusion proteins by immunoassay. We used a human IgM DNA sequence encoding the heavy chain domains 3–5, which Fukuda’s laboratory used to detect binding partners of L-selectin and E-selectin by fluorescence microscopy [4]. IgG1a fusion proteins were encoded by SigpIg+ vectors (R&D Systems). The complementary deoxyribonucleic acid (cDNA) for mouse PD-L1 was from OpenBiosystems (Huntsville, AL, USA). The J-chain DNA sequence was from cDNA from the human B-cell line Raji, cloned into pCIPac DNA plasmid [14]. The DNA vector encoding the PD-1-rCD4 fusion protein was as published [15]. Fusion proteins (see Supporting Information Materials and Methods and Supporting Information Fig. 1 for detailed information) were expressed by transiently or stably transfected HEK-293 cells. When the J-chain was transiently cotransfected, a ratio of IgM fusion protein DNA to J-chain DNA of 10:1 was chosen. The concentration of the IgG or IgM fusion proteins in cell culture medium was measured using a standard sandwich enzymelinked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) protocol. IgG or IgM fusions were found to be expressed at similar concentrations and were functional after storage for 1 year in Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s Medium (DMEM) with 10% FCS and 0.01% azide at 4◦C. To assess the advantage of IgM + J-chain constructs by flow cytometry, we monitored binding of mouse PD-L1 molecule to CD3+ primary mouse T cells which express its ligand PD-1 when activated. PD-L1 binds PD-1 with a dissociation constant of 0.77 μM, and B7–1 of 1.4 μM [16]. We also used mouse BTN2A2, which binds to T cells through an unknown receptor [17]. First, we compared binding of PD-L1-IgG and BTN2A2-IgG fusion proteins with their IgM counterparts. PD-L1-IgG fusion proteins did not