Low Delta O-18 Values Of Nitrate Produced From Nitrification In Temperate Forest Soils

Yunting Fang,Keisuke Koba,Akiko Makabe,Feifei Zhu,Shaoyan Fan,Xueyan Liu,Muneoki Yoh
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/es300510r
IF: 11.4
2012-01-01
Environmental Science & Technology
Abstract:Analyses of delta O-18 of nitrate (NO3-) have been widely used in partitioning NO3- sources. However the delta O-18 value of NO3- produced from nitrification (microbial NO3-) is commonly estimated using the delta O-18 of environmental water and molecular oxygen in a 2:1 ratio. Here our laboratory incubation of nine temperate forest soils across a 1500 m elevation gradient demonstrates that microbial NO3- has lower delta O-18 values than the predicted using the 2:1 ratio (by 5.2-9.5 parts per thousand at low elevation sites), in contrast to previous reports showing higher delta O-18 values (up to +15 parts per thousand) than their predicted values. Elevated delta O-18 values of microbial NO3- were observed at high elevation sites where soil was more acidic, perhaps due to accelerated O-exchange between nitrite, an intermediate product of nitrification, and water. Lower delta O-18 of microbial NO3- than the predicted and from previous observations suggests that the contribution of anthropogenic N inputs, such as fertilizer and atmospheric deposition, to a given ecosystem and the progress of denitrification in nitrogen removal are greater than we know. More than half of the delta O-18 of stream NO3- lower than the predicted value along the elevation gradient also indicate the impropriety using the 2:1 ratio for differentiating NO3- sources.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?