Abstract:PurposeThe use of life cycle assessment (LCA) as a decision support tool can be hampered by the numerous uncertainties embedded in the calculation. The treatment of uncertainty is necessary to increase the reliability and credibility of LCA results. The objective is to provide an overview of the methods to identify, characterize, propagate (uncertainty analysis), understand the effects (sensitivity analysis), and communicate uncertainty in order to propose recommendations to a broad public of LCA practitioners.MethodsThis work was carried out via a literature review and an analysis of LCA tool functionalities. In order to facilitate the identification of uncertainty, its location within an LCA model was distinguished between quantity (any numerical data), model structure (relationships structure), and context (criteria chosen within the goal and scope of the study). The methods for uncertainty characterization, uncertainty analysis, and sensitivity analysis were classified according to the information provided, their implementation in LCA software, the time and effort required to apply them, and their reliability and validity. This review led to the definition of recommendations on three levels: basic (low efforts with LCA software), intermediate (significant efforts with LCA software), and advanced (significant efforts with non-LCA software).Results and discussionFor the basic recommendations, minimum and maximum values (quantity uncertainty) and alternative scenarios (model structure/context uncertainty) are defined for critical elements in order to estimate the range of results. Result sensitivity is analyzed via one-at-a-time variations (with realistic ranges of quantities) and scenario analyses. Uncertainty should be discussed at least qualitatively in a dedicated paragraph. For the intermediate level, the characterization can be refined with probability distributions and an expert review for scenario definition. Uncertainty analysis can then be performed with the Monte Carlo method for the different scenarios. Quantitative information should appear in inventory tables and result figures. Finally, advanced practitioners can screen uncertainty sources more exhaustively, include correlations, estimate model error with validation data, and perform Latin hypercube sampling and global sensitivity analysis.ConclusionsThrough this pedagogic review of the methods and practical recommendations, the authors aim to increase the knowledge of LCA practitioners related to uncertainty and facilitate the application of treatment techniques. To continue in this direction, further research questions should be investigated (e.g., on the implementation of fuzzy logic and model uncertainty characterization) and the developers of databases, LCIA methods, and software tools should invest efforts in better implementing and treating uncertainty in LCA.

LCA data quality assessment and control based on uncertainty and sensitivity analysis

Data Quality Assessment of the Uncertainty Analysis Applied to the Greenhouse Gas Emissions of a Dairy Cow System

How to treat uncertainties in life cycle assessment studies?

Life Cycle Assessment under Uncertainty: A Scoping Review

Product life cycle assessment and environmental efficiency assessment

Statistical Based Approach for Uncertainty Analysis in Life Cycle Assessment: a Case Study in Textile Industry.

Knowledge Graph-Based Mapping and Recommendation to Automate Life Cycle Assessment

The importance of uncertainty sources in LCA for the reliability of environmental comparisons: A case study on public bus fleet electrification

Product Quality & Cost Control Method Based on Set Pair Analysis and Evolutionary Cellular Learning Automata

Classification of sources of uncertainties in building LCA

Coupling life cycle assessment and life cycle costing as an evaluation tool for developing product service system of high energy-consuming equipment

Global Sensitivity Analysis in Life-Cycle Assessment of Early-Stage Technology using Detailed Process Simulation: Application to Dialkylimidazolium Ionic Liquid Production

Life Cycle Assessment: a review of the methodology and its application to sustainability

Software design of LCA for coal-fired power generation purposes Life Cycle Assessment

Weighted least squares and quasi-weighted least squares combined method for data rectification

Estimating Missing Unit Process Data in Life Cycle Assessment Using a Similarity-based Approach.

Development and demonstration of an uncertainty management methodology for life cycle assessment in a tiered-hybrid case study of an Irish apartment development

Tackling uncertainty in life cycle assessments for the built environment: A review

Contribution-based prioritization of LCI database improvements: the most important unit processes in ecoinvent

Life-cycle Assessment(lca)and Its Software Development in the Hydrogen Resources for FCV