Construction des espaces urbains et renovation d'un quartier de Shanghai: la problematique de la migration et du changement social (Construction of urban spaces and renovation of a community of Shanghai: The problematic of migration and social change) [Book Review]
Emmanuel Caron
2012-10-01
Abstract:(ProQuest: ... denotes non-US-ASCII text omitted.)Zhao Yeqin, Construction des espaces urbains et renovation d'un quartier de Shanghai: la problematique de la migration et du changement social (Construction of urban spaces and renovation of a community of Shanghai: The problematic of migration and social change), Shanghai, Shanghai Sanlian Shudian, 430 pp.Over the past two decades, Chinese cities have undergone extremely rapid change, first due to major internal migratory waves towards urban areas following a loosening of the hukousystem, and second due to the burgeoning renovation projects and urban development on a mammoth scale. Zhao Yeqin's book deals with the joint effect of these two phenomena on an old neighbourhood in urban Shanghai "earmarked for renovation" and where many migrants live. The ethnographic survey carried out over two periods of ten months between 2004 and 2007 provides a window for observing social changes underway. The main subject of the study, relations between urban residents(1)and migrants, goes beyond China by looking at a recurring question in urban sociology, namely cohabitation of different social groups within the same space. The author adheres to a rich sociological tradition, tapping sources in the Chicago school as well as French urban sociology. The exigencies of the Chinese context have not been overlooked: the author has taken pains to set out the historical context, both national and local, that led to the evolution of the situation studied.It should be noted that this book, published in French by a Chinese pub- lishing house, is based on a thesis completed in 2008 for ENS Cachan and East China Normal University. No doubt the choice of publishing in French in China deprived the work of editing that would not only have helped clar- ify arguments developed but also would have improved overall readability. The first part (chapters 1 and 2), focusing on theory and methodology, often overlaps with the second part containing fieldwork analysis. The richness of references certainly testifies to a concern for showing the theoretical bases for the reflection, but it is regrettable that not all are rendered operational through direct linkages with empirical findings. The quality of the findings, however, testifies to the author's immersion in the field. In-depth interviews with both migrants and urban residents are well-detailed and enable the author to tell their life stories and clarify the thesis.The second part, containing two-thirds of the book, begins by introducing the neighbourhood studied, Yuanhenong (chapters 3 to 5).(2)The people there are described in minute detail, and photographs supplement physical descriptions of the places. To start with, recent changes in the neighbour- hood are presented in the context of its longer history. Its origins as a slum in the early twentieth century,(3) its development following the establish- ment of a textile factory nearby, and its closure in the early 1990s resulting in major unemployment among residents, are all narrated. In this context, the arrival of migrants from many provinces - mainly Anhui, Jiangsu, and Henan - is superimposed on ongoing transformations, setting off a move- ment of residents renting out their dwellings, and in some cases moving out of the neighbourhood.Using life stories, the author details migrants' residential trajectories after arriving in Shanghai and notes typical tendencies: 1) installation in the neighbourhood at the "end of a process punctuated by intermediary halts"; 2) "sojourn awaiting a move to a posher neighbourhood"; and finally, 3) the "result of a direct migratory trajectory." The details of these trajectories are of major interest as they help delineate the inflection points - change of job, conflict with a lodger, etc. - that led to the change of accommodation. The above typology, is however, less convincing by itself, as it seems to neg- lect the dynamic nature of these trajectories, presenting the first and third type of installation in Yuanhenong as the end of the residential trajectory. …
Sociology