Application and comparison of calculative models for dynamic time history analysis of steel frame under strong earthquake

Meng Wang,Yongjiu Shi,Yuanqing Wang

2012-01-01

Abstract:In order to compare the calculation accuracy and efficiency of several models for steel frame time history analysis, shell element model, multi-scale model, fiber ECM and bilinear model were established by software ABAQUS. The structural deformation and structural failure modes were compared. The calculated efficiency of ECM was verified. The effects of damage and degradation on steel frame seismic behaviors were discussed in depth. The results show that: Before the occurrence of damage and degradation, seismic indexes calculated by four models were in accordance. Once plastic strain accumulation caused damage and degradation, the calculated results of ECM, shell element model and multi-scale model were basically the same, which indicated ECM reflected the enlarged effect of deformation. While the results of traditional bilinear model were relatively smaller than the other three models, which meant it overestimated the collapse resistance of the structure, leading to unsafe design. For calculation efficiency, the calculated time of ECM was far fewer than shell element model and multi-scale model, and a little more than bilinear model. ECM was a balanced solution between accuracy and computational cost.