Abstract:A prevalent assumption in auction theory is that the auctioneer has full control over the market and that the allocation she dictates is final. In practice, however, agents might be able to resell acquired items in an aftermarket. A prominent example is the market for carbon emission allowances. These allowances are commonly allocated by the government using uniform-price auctions, and firms can typically trade these allowances among themselves in an aftermarket that may not be fully under the auctioneer's control. While the uniform-price auction is approximately efficient in isolation, we show that speculation and resale in aftermarkets might result in a significant welfare loss. Motivated by this issue, we consider three approaches, each ensuring high equilibrium welfare in the combined market. The first approach is to adopt smooth auctions such as discriminatory auctions. This approach is robust to correlated valuations and to participants acquiring information about others' types. However, discriminatory auctions have several downsides, notably that of charging bidders different prices for identical items, resulting in fairness concerns that make the format unpopular. Two other approaches we suggest are either using posted-pricing mechanisms, or using uniform-price auctions with anonymous reserves. We show that when using balanced prices, both these approaches ensure high equilibrium welfare in the combined market. The latter also inherits many of the benefits from uniform-price auctions such as price discovery, and can be introduced with a minor modification to auctions currently in use to sell carbon emission allowances.

Computational Simulation on Auction Pricing of Property Rights Based on the Wealth Utility

The Social Construction Logic of Property Rights:A review on the property rights studies of Chinese sociologists from the perspective of game theory

Data Pricing Mechanism Based on Property Rights Compensation Distribution

Auctions Versus Posted-Price Selling

Auctions Versus Posted-Price Selling: the Case of Correlated Private Valuations

Utility theory in land expropriation pricing

Price game and chaos control among three oligarchs with different rationalities in property insurance market

Making Auctions Robust to Aftermarkets

Goodwill Can Hurt: A Theoretical and Experimental Investigation of Return Policies in Auctions.

Intellectual Property Rights Protection in the Cumulative Innovation:An Auction Model

Multi-Market Bidding Strategy of Power Suppliers

Learning Buyers' Valuation Distribution in Posted-Price Selling

Strategic behavior in dynamic auctions

An Explanation of Inefficiency in Markets and A Justification for Buy-And-Hold Strategies

Positive Game Analysis on Land Bidding Sale in Hangzhou

The price-bidding strategy for investors in a renewable auction: An option games–based study

BILATERAL MATCHING DECISION-MAKING IN PROPERTY TRADING PLATFORM: A METHOD CONSIDERING INTERMEDIARY MORAL HAZARD

Valuation of Long-Term Property Rights under Political Uncertainty

The behavior evolution and case simulation of water rights trading in water transfer projects

Advertising a second-price auction

Behind Bargaining: A Jurisprudential Comment on the Selling Mode in Present Markets