Sustainability Assessment Tools for Dairy Supply Chains: A Typology

Rita Paçarada,Stefan Hörtenhuber,Torsten Hemme,Maria Wurzinger,Werner Zollitsch

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16124999

IF: 3.9

2024-06-13

Sustainability

Abstract:The dairy sector faces increasing pressure to adopt sustainable practices. Various tools have been developed to evaluate sustainability of the dairy supply chain. This paper provides an overview of these tools, highlighting their strengths and limitations regarding sustainability dimensions, indicators, and system boundaries. A systematic literature search identified 27 tools that were then categorized into a typology based on dimensions of sustainability, geographical applicability, and accessibility. In-depth analysis was conducted on six tools: Sustainability Assessment of Food and Agriculture (SAFA), Sustainability Monitoring and Assessment RouTine (SMART), Response-Inducing Sustainability Evaluation (RISE) 3.0 version, Swiss Agricultural Life Cycle Assessment (SALCAsustain), MOnitoring Tool for Integrated Farm Sustainability (MOTIFS), and Technology Impact and Policy Impact CALculations (TIPICAL). Assessment focused on the relevance of covered sustainability dimensions to the dairy sector, level of supply chain coverage, type of indicators, accessibility, and practicability. The review identified tools which integrate multiple sustainability aspects in a comprehensive way (SAFA and SMART) and tools offering accurate quantification of the impact on sustainability dimensions of the production system (SALCAsustain, RISE, MOTIFS, TIPICAL). Only two tools extend assessment past the farm gate (SAFA, SMART). Future users should select tools based on the specific objectives of measuring sustainability in dairy systems. This review contributes to the literature by addressing various aspects of sustainability assessment tools, by addressing the need for an integrated and comprehensive view, and by considering the entire dairy supply chain.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main aim of this paper is to address the challenges in sustainability assessment within the dairy industry and to provide a comprehensive and practical guide for selecting tools for relevant practitioners.

The core issue of the paper is to identify and analyze sustainability assessment tools applicable to the dairy supply chain. Through a literature review, the authors systematically screened a large amount of relevant research material and ultimately identified 27 sustainability assessment tools for classification and discussion. On this basis, they further selected 6 tools for in-depth analysis, covering at least three sustainability dimensions: environmental integrity, economic resilience, and social well-being.

Specifically, the objectives of the paper include:
1. **Overview of existing tools**: Provide an overview of the existing tools used to assess the sustainability of the dairy supply chain.
2. **Classification of tools**: Classify these tools based on sustainability dimensions (such as environmental, economic, and social), geographic applicability, and accessibility.
3. **In-depth analysis of specific tools**: Select 6 tools for detailed review, which have good coverage in terms of sustainability dimensions and are accessible globally or regionally.
4. **Provide guidance**: Offer guidance to stakeholders in the dairy supply chain on how to choose appropriate sustainability assessment tools.

Through the above work, the paper hopes to help participants in the dairy industry better understand the importance of sustainability assessment and provide them with practical tool selection criteria to promote sustainable development practices across the industry.