Experiential Learning as a Path to Critical Consciousness in the Medical Curriculum: A Qualitative Study
Ellen Barnidge,Ally Terhaar,Gene LaBarge,Joshua Arthur
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/23821205241264700
2024-07-25
Abstract:Objectives: Clinical settings are increasingly focused on addressing patients' social needs, thus medical education must prepare future clinicians for this task. Critical consciousness, an awareness that puts health within a broader social, historical, and cultural context, could help shape students' understanding of patient social needs. Our paper explores how experiential learning through participation in a social care intervention deepened students' critical consciousness, or their understanding of the systems and structures that make it difficult for patients to meet their basic needs. Methods: We conducted one-on-one semistructured interviews with all 24 students who served as advocates for the intervention. Of the 24 advocates, 75% (n = 18) were first-year medical students, 17% (n = 4) were public health students, and 8% (n = 2) were social work students. Interviews were audiorecorded, transcribed verbatim, and analyzed using framework analysis. Results: We identified themes informed by critical consciousness, including individual (assumptions and biases), interpersonal (communication and relationship), and structural (organization and power) factors. Within these categories, advocates expressed deeper self-awareness of personal biases (individual), the importance of interpersonal communication to build trust with caregivers (interpersonal), and the identification of the structural factors that influence health, such as housing conditions (structural). The advocates highlighted the importance of experiential learning to help them understand social determinants of health. By witnessing multiple patients experiencing social needs, advocates saw the cascading effects of social needs, the structures that make it difficult to meet basic needs, and the effect on health and healthcare behavior. Conclusion: Students engaged in the intervention demonstrated the development of critical consciousness. Although limited, our findings suggest that when students engage with patients around social needs, students can better understand the broader social context of patients' lives. Experiential learning through social care interventions may have the potential to influence critical consciousness development and shape the practice of future clinicians.