Abstract:Key Points Histone post-translational modifications (PTMs) have numerous crucial roles in genome management, in part by recruiting or stabilizing chemical or structural modification activities. These recruited effector complexes are often composed of several domains that have been linked to modified histone recognition, and perform functions ranging from promoting transcription to establishing gene silencing. We propose that multivalent interactions that are PTM dependent may act in concert to physically regulate chromatin structure and DNA-templated transactions. In principle, these cooperative binding interactions may yield enhanced net affinity, increased composite specificity and greater dynamics relative to similarly tight monovalent interactions. We give a general description of chromatin marks that are known to coexist spatially and describe the experimental technologies used to establish these findings. Patterns of these modifications together may form substrates for multivalent recognition at the single-nucleosome level and beyond, which appear to dictate functional consequences. The biophysics of multivalency has been well developed in other fields but is largely underappreciated and understudied in chromatin biology. We draw from the lessons learned in these other fields in describing how the thermodynamic principles of multivalency may explain several concerns about the histone code hypothesis. In particular, the weak affinities and often modest specificities intrinsic to a given histone-binding domain may be altered substantially when linked to a multivalent effector polypeptide or complex. Although a well-characterized example that systematically describes multivalent effects on chromatin substrates is still lacking, we describe examples from the literature that are beginning to suggest the multivalent recognition theme. We hope to exhort further efforts to study this phenomenon and, to this end, propose a classification scheme to help clarify different putative modes of chromatin engagement.

Mathematical modeling of histone modifications reveals the formation mechanism and function of bivalent chromatin

Modeling of histone modifications reveals formation mechanism and function of bivalent chromatin

Modeling the dynamics of bivalent histone modifications

Histone H3 Lysine 4 Monomethylation Modulates Long-Range Chromatin Interactions at Enhancers

Histone H3 lysine 4 monomethylation modulates longrange chromatin interactions at enhancers (vol 28, pg 204, 2018)

Identification of H3K4me1-associated Proteins at Mammalian Enhancers

A computational model for histone mark propagation reproduces the distribution of heterochromatin in different human cell types

Multivalent engagement of chromatin modifications by linked binding modules

Inter-nucleosomal Communication Between Histone Modifications for Nucleosome Phasing

Computational modeling to elucidate molecular mechanisms of epigenetic memory

Bivalent chromatin: a developmental balancing act tipped in cancer

A model of dynamic stability of H3K9me3 heterochromatin to explain the resistance to reprogramming of differentiated cells

Importance of Electrostatic Interactions in the Association of Intrinsically Disordered Histone Chaperone Chz1 and Histone H2A.Z-H2B.

Histone Modifications Regulate Chromatin Compartmentalization by Contributing to a Phase Separation Mechanism.

Dynamical phase transition in models that couple chromatin folding with histone modifications

Structural Modeling of Chromatin Integrates Genome Features and Reveals Chromosome Folding Principle

The role of multiple marks in epigenetic silencing and the emergence of a stable bivalent chromatin state

Connected Chromatin Amplifies Acetylation-modulated Nucleosome Interactions

The intriguing dynamics of chromatin folding and assembly

Dynamic regulation of histone modifications and long-range chromosomal interactions during postmitotic transcriptional reactivation

The many faces of H3.3 in regulating chromatin in embryonic stem cells and beyond