Abstract:Religion and Society in England 1850-1914. By Hugh McLeod. Social History in Perspective. New York, NY: St. Martin's Press, 1996. viii + 267 pp. $18.95 (paper). Religion in the Age of Decline: Organisation and Experience in Industrial Yorkshire, 1870-1920. By S. J. D. Green. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996. xv + 426 pp. $69.95 (cloth). One of the long standing chestnuts in the popular historical imagination is the Victorian crisis of faith, and the resulting triumph of a secularized English society. The alleged causes were urbanization, industrialization, and the advance of new forms of knowledge, and the assumed period of this change was the end of the nineteenth century. This account is peopled by persons like Leslie Stephen and T. H. Huxley. But over the last two decades scholars have increasingly challenged the dating, the causes, and even the reality of this phenomenon. These two volumes are reflective of this new scholarly thrust. These volumes share much in common. Both steer clear of the standard pictures of intellectual and ecclesiastical historians and argue for a picture of religious life from the bottom up, focusing upon everyday laypersons and not simply clerics and intellectuals. Their focus is on the religious life and culture of the late nineteenth century, with its Sunday schools, mutual aid societies, and still-distinguishable Sabbath observances. Both also set forth a picture of English society still strongly marked by Christian influences. These, they note, were not always for the most elevated of motives. Each writer, for example, takes delight in recounting that the popularity of Sunday afternoon Sunday schools in large part rested upon the fact that this time allowed for parents to have their conjugal relations undisturbed! But they are different books with different agendas. McLeod's volume is a broad synthetic survey resting on a surfeit of secondary literature and a number of oral history projects that attempted to record lay religious practices and beliefs in late nineteenth century Britain. His work centers on three interrelated questions: 1) the class make-up of the Victorian religious boom, 2) whether Victorian religion was an agent of social control or a force for reform and social criticism, and 3) why this religious boom came to an end. The picture he draws is a mixed one. Tie argues that although religious affiliation did increase as one's social position advanced, a large percentage of working class persons were at least tangentially connected with religious communities and that family hymn singing and other Sunday rituals continued to be popular. Regarding his final question, McLeod argues that although a high degree of religious consensus did decline between 1850 and 1914 it had not yet completely broken down. To explain the decline he appeals to the principle of "privatization" rather than secularization. …

Alehouses and Conflicts over Culture and Values in Early Modern England

The art market during a period of class transition in 19th-century England: A case study of the Agnew family

Alcohol, Drunkenness, and Excess—Consumption and Transgression in European Medieval and Early Modern Literature

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Alcoholic Beverages

Struggling for Livelihood: Social Conflict through the Teahouse in Republican Chengdu

Beer, brewing, and regional studies

Hume On The Protestant Ethic And The Rise Of English Commercial Spirit

Regulating Alcohol Consumption and Structuring Life in Dickens's Our Mutual Friend

Research On the Current Problem and Marketing Strategy of Helen’s Market

The Earliest Toasts

The Patriarchalism in English Political Culture During the 16th and 17th Centuries

Religion and Society in England 1850-1914 / Religion in the Age of Decline: Organisation and Experience in Industrial Yorkshire, 1870-1920

New Developments in the Brewing Industry

Reorganization of Guilds and State Control of Small Business: A Case Study of the Teahouse Guild in Early 1950s Chengdu

Skepticism in Early Modern English Literature

The Exotic Country in the Quarrel of the Ancients and the Moderns: Images of China in the Battle of the Books

Down the local: A qualitative case study of daytime drinking spaces in the London Borough of Islington

Temperance and Self-Determination in the British Isles

Brewing difference: malting, gender and urbanity in medieval England. An examination of drying and malting kilns, c.1150–1500

Negotiating Religious and Cultural Diversity in Tang China: An Analysis of the Cha jiu lun 茶酒論

Dickens’s literary defences of moderate drinking