Abstract:Transdermal delivery of therapeutic molecules is often hindered by the properties of the skin, with the stratum corneum serving as the primary permeation barrier. To overcome this barrier, the integrity of the stratum corneum can be modified by chemical permeation enhancers, such as deep eutectic solvents (DESs), or by mechanically impairing the skin with microneedles (MNs). However, a systematic comparison between these strategies is currently lacking. Hence, this study examined the potential of DESs and MNs to promote the permeation and retention of drugs with varying lipophilicities - specifically, the hydrophilic drug metronidazole (logP ∼ 0), the moderately lipophilic drug lidocaine (logP ∼ 2.3), and the highly lipophilic drug clotrimazole (logP ∼ 5). A mixture of menthol and thymol was selected as a model terpene-based DES and delivery vehicle, while a DermaPen equipped with solid MNs was used to mechanically impair the skin. Permeation rates of model drugs applied to the skin with either DES, MNs, or both were compared to the rates determined for the drugs applied in control vehicles. Both strategies were found to compromise the skin barrier function, but their permeation-enhancing effect was dependent on the lipophilicity of tested model drug. The DES was most effective for the hydrophilic drug metronidazole, while the MNs were more effective in increasing the permeation of the highly lipophilic drug clotrimazole. For the moderately lipophilic drug lidocaine, neither the DES nor MNs increased its permeation rate, as the drug permeated through the skin well on its own. Notably, the combination of both enhancement strategies did not result in significantly better permeation rates of the drugs compared to the individual approaches. In conclusion, both the terpene-based DES and solid MNs are effective strategies to enhance drug permeation through the skin, but our results suggest that the choice of strategy should be dictated by the drug's lipophilicity. Moreover, from a permeation-enhancing perspective, there is no benefit in combining these two strategies.

Physicochemical effects of terpenes on organogel for transdermal drug delivery

Limonene GP1/PG organogel as a vehicle in transdermal delivery of haloperidol

Preparation and pharmacodynamics studies on anti-inflammatory effect of catechu gel

Effect of Terpenes on the Enhancement of Skin Permeation of Lipophilic Drugs: A Systematic Review

A review on terpenes as skin penetration enhancers in transdermal drug delivery.

Effect of terpenes on the skin permeation of lomerizine dihydrochloride

Investigation of β-caryophyllene as terpene penetration enhancer: Role of stratum corneum retention

Formulation development of transdermal dosage forms: quantitative structure-activity relationship model for predicting activities of terpenes that enhance drug penetration through human skin.

Effects Of Carbopol (R) 934 Proportion On Nanoemulsion Gel For Topical And Transdermal Drug Delivery: A Skin Permeation Study

Effect of molecular polarity on the transdermal permeability of Dihydropyridine calcium antagonist gels

Drug permeation through skin is inversely correlated with carrier gel rigidity.

Molecular Insights into the Penetration Enhancement Mechanism of Terpenes to Skin

The enhancing effect and promoting mechanisms of the stereoisomeric monoterpene alcohol esters as enhancers for drugs with different physicochemical properties

[Effect of terpene penetration enhancer and its mechanisms on membrane fluidity and potential of HaCaT keratinocytes].

Development of galangal essential oil-based microemulsion gel for transdermal delivery of flurbiprofen: simultaneous permeability evaluation of flurbiprofen and 1,8-cineole

Investigation of the enhancement effect of the natural transdermal permeation enhancers from Ledum palustre L. var. angustum N. Busch: Mechanistic insight based on interaction among drug, enhancers and skin.

Evaluation of molecular interaction between intercellular lipid organization in human stratum corneum and terpenes using time-resolved synchrotron X-ray diffraction

Comparing effects of terpene-based deep eutectic solvent and solid microneedles on skin permeation of drugs with varying lipophilicity

Monoterpenes-containing PEGylated Transfersomes for Enhancing Joint Cavity Drug Delivery Evidenced by CLSM and Double-Sited Microdialysis.

Preparation of 3, 5, 4'-trimethoxy-trans-stilbene and its transdermal absorption ex vivo

Using Raman Spectroscopy in Studying the Effect of Propylene Glycol, Oleic Acid, and Their Combination on the Rat Skin