The Validity of Transformational and Transactional Leadership Model

Qingjuan WANG

2008-01-01

Abstract:This paper first explains transformational versus transactional leadership model and its underlying assumptions;then discusses its empirical and theoretical reasonableness pertaining these assumptions;limitations about the model are examined next;finally,future research directions are suggested.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

How Transformational Leadership Affects Teacher Collective Efficacy? the Mediating Role of Professional Learning Communities and the Moderating Role of Trust

Jia Zhang,Zhihui Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02188791.2023.2270173

IF: 1.478

2023-01-01

Asia Pacific Journal of Education

Abstract:This study explored the mediating role of professional learning communities (PLCs) and the moderating role of principals' perceived trust by teachers in the effect of transformational leadership on teacher collective efficacy from Chinese principals' perspective. A survey was conducted among 822 principals in China. Data were analysed using structural equation modelling and bootstrapping. The results showed that transformational leadership had a significant and positive effect on teacher collective efficacy. PLCs significantly and fully mediated the effect of transformational leadership on teacher collective efficacy. Principals' perceived trust by teachers significantly and negatively moderated the effect of transformational leadership on PLCs. This study advanced our understanding of how transformational leadership affected teacher collective efficacy, and added the crucial perspective of principals to research in this field. The study also enriches the existing literature on the relationship between principals' transformational leadership and teacher collective efficacy in Chinese context. Practical implications and suggestions for future research are discussed.
An Empirical Study of the Female Entrepreneur Leadership Model in China

Jian-ying HU,Qin-feng JIANG,Zhong-ming WANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13806/j.cnki.issn1008-7095.2008.06.011

2008-01-01

Abstract:Leadership models have been studied in the academia from such perspectives as leaders’characteristics,individual behavior,and environment.This paper applies the findings of recent research abroad to China,focusing on the leadership models of female Chinese entrepreneurs.The study finds that female Chinese entrepreneurs use five leadership models,i.e.people-oriented leadership,innovational leadership,transformational leadership,harmonious leadership and transactional leadership.
The Study of Effectiveness Conversion of Cross-Cultural Leadership Modes in Major Developmental Phases of International Enterprises

Shi-yuan LIN,Zhong-ming WANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1006-6020.2006.03.005

2006-01-01

Abstract:Based on the leadership theory in managerial psychology,this empirical study investigated the effectiveness conversion of cross-cultural leadership modes in the three major developmental phases of international enterprises,using a semi-structured interview,questionnaires,and statistical analysis.The results showed:(1) The effectiveness of transformational leadership,entrepreneurial leadership,and transactional leadership demonstrated significant differences in the three major developmental stages;(2) Transactional leadership had the strongest effect in the growing stage,and the weakest in the mature stage;(3) Entrepreneurial leadership had the strongest effect in the expanding stage,and the weakest in the mature stage;(4) Transformational leadership had the strongest effect in the mature stage,and the weakest in the growing stage.
Transformational and Transactional Leadership: A Meta-Analytic Test of Their Relative Validity.

Timothy A. Judge,Ronald F. Piccolo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.89.5.755

IF: 11.8025

2004-01-01

Journal of Applied Psychology

Abstract:This study provided a comprehensive examination of the full range of transformational, transactional, and laissez-faire leadership. Results (based on 626 correlations from 87 sources) revealed an overall validity of .44 for transformational leadership, and this validity generalized over longitudinal and multisource designs. Contingent reward (.39) and laissez-faire (-.37) leadership had the next highest overall relations; management by exception (active and passive) was inconsistently related to the criteria. Surprisingly, there were several criteria for which contingent reward leadership had stronger relations than did transformational leadership. Furthermore, transformational leadership was strongly correlated with contingent reward (.80) and laissez-faire (-.65) leadership. Transformational and contingent reward leadership generally predicted criteria controlling for the other leadership dimensions, although transformational leadership failed to predict leader job performance.

psychology, applied,management
For the Good or the Bad? Interactive Effects of Transformational Leadership with Moral and Authoritarian Leadership Behaviors

Sebastian C. Schuh,Xin-an Zhang,Peng Tian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-012-1486-0

IF: 6.331

2013-01-01

Journal of Business Ethics

Abstract:Although the ethical aspects of transformational leadership have attracted considerable attention, very little is known about followers’ reactions to the moral and immoral conduct of transformational leaders. Against this background, this study examined whether and how transformational leadership interacts with moral and authoritarian leadership behaviors in predicting followers’ in-role and extra-role efforts. Building on attribution theory, we hypothesized that the positive and negative effects of these leadership behaviors would be particularly pronounced for highly transformational leaders given that this leadership style elicits strong attention and sense-making efforts among followers. We tested our model in a sample of 228 individuals comprising 114 leader–follower dyads from a wide range of organizations and industries. In line with our hypotheses, results revealed that for highly transformational leaders, moral leadership behaviors related positively to employees’ in-role and extra-role efforts whereas authoritarian leadership behaviors related negatively to employees’ in-role and extra-role efforts. In contrast, moral and authoritarian leadership behaviors did not significantly affect followers’ reactions to leaders low in transformational leadership. Taken together, these findings suggest that transformational leadership, contrary to its largely positive perception in the literature, can be a rather mixed blessing. Implications for theory, future research, and managerial practice are discussed.
Leadership in the Transformation:The summary and comment of transformational leadership theory

Wu Qiong,Shi Jianjun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-8263.2010.02.007

2010-01-01

Abstract:On the basis of relevant literatures of transformational leadership at home and abroad,this thesis takes compositive critics on the definition,dimension,measure and mechanism of action of transformational leadership.It builds a systematic angle of view to comprehend the profound meaning of transformational leadership theory,which includes three spheres for completely analyzing this theory,such as individual sphere of it,the sphere of relationship between transformational leadership and subordination group and the sphere of relationship between transformational leadership and organization of environment.
Transformational Leadership and Employees’ Reactions to Organizational Change: Evidence From a Meta-Analysis

Jian Peng,Mingze Li,Zhen Wang,Yuying Lin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0021886320920366

2020-05-15

The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science

Abstract:Numerous studies have empirically tested the linkage between transformational leadership and employees’ reactions to organizational change. However, no systematic attempt has been made to organize and summarize those findings. Based on a sample of 30 empirical studies that included 39 independent effect sizes and 12,240 participants, this meta-analysis found that transformational leadership exhibited (a) a positive relationship with commitment to change, openness to change, and readiness for change; (b) a negative correlation with resistance to change and cynicism about change; and (c) a nonsignificant correlation with support for change. Moderation analyses showed that in cross-sectional (vs. longitudinal) designs, transformational leadership exhibited a stronger correlation with openness to change and cynicism about change. Using Bass and Avolio’s scale (vs. Podsakoff et al.’s), transformational leadership exhibited a stronger correlation with resistance to change. In the Eastern (vs. Western) cultural context, transformational leadership exhibited a stronger correlation with commitment to change and resistance to change. In low-level (vs. high-level) journals, transformational leadership exhibited a stronger correlation with commitment to change, openness to change, and support for change. This study highlights the value of incorporating transformational leadership theory into the literature on change reactions to obtain a better understanding of how leaders facilitate or hinder organizational change.
Empirical Study on Transformational Leadership, Organizational Commitment and Turnover Intention in Chinese Context

CHEN Chih-Chung,ZHANG De

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-2848.2010.01.002

2010-01-01

Abstract:Transformational leadership is a hot issue in leadership and organizational behavior researches. Transformational leadership,however,is a western-based concept,and empirical researches in Chinese context are insufficient. This research firstly revises and tests the measure scales of transformational leadership in Chinese context. Through reliability analysis and confirmatory factor analysis (CFA),the revised transformational leadership questionnaire has been proved to be reliable and valid. Based on a survey of 480 employees,we conclude that transformational leadership has positive effect on organizational commitment and negative effect on resigning intention.
The Impact of Transformational Leadership and Transactional Leadership on Voice Behavior and Creative Behavior through Job Crafting

Hang-Hang Cui,Hyeok-Gi Kwon,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.20294/jgbt.2023.19.3.111

2023-06-30

International Academy of Global Business and Trade

Abstract:Purpose - In the face of an increasingly competitive business environment and the growing complexity and dynamism of work activities, employee voice and creative behaviors are essential to organizational growth and survival. Consequently, this study examines how to increase voice and creative behaviors in organizational life using transformational leadership and transactional leadership as the entry points, and selecting job crafting as the mediating variable. Design/Methodology/Approach - A hypothesized model was developed to examine the relationship between the constructs. The sample for the study comprised 364 Chinese employees. Data were analyzed using SPSS and structural equation modelling in AMOS. Findings - Transformational leadership and transactional leadership positively impact job crafting, voice behavior, and creative behavior, complementing the existing theory. Furthermore, this study finds that through job crafting, transformational leadership has an enhanced impact on voice and creative behaviors. Research Implications - Transformational leadership and transactional leadership are two separate and complementary types of leadership. Therefore, organizations should develop leaders that can flexibly use both styles to improve leadership effectiveness. Furthermore, the organization should pay more attention to employee job crafting, voice behavior, and creative behavior. Organizations or supervisors should appropriately grant employees work autonomy to respond to the rapidly changing external environment.
Leader-Member Exchange As A,Mediator of the Relationship Between Transformational Leadership and Followers' Performance and Organizational Citizenship Behavior

H Wang,KS Law,RD Hackett,DX Wang,ZX Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2005.17407908

IF: 10.5

2005-01-01

Academy of Management Journal

Abstract:We developed a model in which leader-member exchange mediated between perceived transformational leadership behaviors and followers' task performance and organizational citizenship behaviors. Our sample comprised 162 leader-follower dyads within organizations situated throughout the People's Republic of China. We showed that leader-member. exchange fully mediated between transformational leadership and task performance as well as organizational citizenship behaviors. Implications for the theory and practice of leadership are discussed, and future research directions offered.
The antecedents and outcomes of transformational leadership: leader's self-transcendent value, follower's environmental commitment and behavior

Shujie Zhang,Wei Sun,Haochen Ji,Junyun Jia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/lodj-10-2020-0471

2021-07-30

Abstract:Purpose The primary purpose of this paper is to identify the antecedent (i.e. leader's self-transcendent value) and outcomes (i.e. follower's environmental commitment and behavior) of transformational leadership. The second purpose is to examine the mediating role of transformational leadership plays in the relationship between leader's self-transcendent value and follower's environmental commitment and behavior. Design/methodology/approach Multi-source data were collected at multiple times in China. A total of 262 employees and their 64 supervisors completed the survey. The authors conducted a series of confirmatory factor analyses (CFAs) to verify the validity of the constructs and adopted the SPSS PROCESS macro with bootstrapping techniques to test the hypotheses. Findings The authors find that leader's self-transcendent value is an important antecedent of transformational leadership, and transformational leadership can enhance followers' environmental commitment and foster their environmental behavior. Besides, transformational leadership plays a significant mediating role between leader's self-transcendent value and follower's environmental commitment and behavior. Originality/value This study has developed an integrated model of the antecedents and outcomes of transformational leadership in the Chinese context. It also confirmed that transformational leadership mediates the process through which leader's self-transcendent value has a positive impact on follower's environmental commitment and behavior.

management
The Impact Of Transformational Leadership On Feedback Seeking Behavior

An Li-Yang,Zhang Li,Zhang Shao-Bin

2015-01-01

Abstract:The study draws on resource perspective to examine the relationship between transformational leadership and employees' feedback-seeking behavior and its contingency. Data was collected from 417 full-time employees from the financial companies in China. Hierarchical regression analysis was employed to test the hypotheses. Results indicated that transformational leadership was negatively associated with feedback-seeking behavior. Core self-evaluations moderated the relationship between them. And with high core self-evaluations, transformational leadership was positively related to feedback-seeking behavior for employees, whereas this relationship for employees with low core self-evaluations was negative. The results present a deeper understanding of how employees weigh various factors in deciding whether to seek feedback within the organization. These findings have important implications for understanding the causes of feedback-seeking behavior under the background of Chinese enterprise culture.
Transformational Leadership and Perceived Overqualification: A Career Development Perspective

Man Zhang,Fan Wang,Haolin Weng,Ting Zhu,Huiyun Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.597821

IF: 3.8

2021-02-11

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:Drawing on social information processing theory and a career development perspective, we examined the effect of transformational leadership on the perceived overqualification via career growth opportunities, and how the supervisor–subordinate guanxi moderates the relationship between transformational leadership and perceived overqualification. We tested this proposal using three waves of lagged data collected from 351 company employees in the Yangtze River Delta region in China. The results revealed that transformational leadership had an indirect effect on perceived overqualification through career growth opportunities, and supervisor–subordinate guanxi moderated the positive association between transformational leadership and career growth opportunities. In addition, the mediating effect of transformational leadership on perceived overqualification through career growth opportunities was stronger when the level of supervisor–subordinate guanxi was high and weaker when it was low. The findings have theoretical and practical implications for reducing employees’ perceptions of overqualification in the organizational context.

psychology, multidisciplinary
Transactional Leadership and Organizational Learning Process

DAI Wanwen,JIANG Jianwu

2010-01-01

Abstract:With the strategic leadership and organizational learning processes theory,this paper challenges the conventional wisdom,which assumes only transformational leadership impacts organizational learning processes by highlighting the value of transactional leadership on the organizational learning processes.The paper develops propositions on how transformational leaders influence organizational learning processes positively to improve the organizational learning theory and provide some practical advices on enhancing organizational learning capability and building learning organization.
Linking Transformational Leadership and Team Performance: A Conflict Management Approach

Xin-an Zhang,Qing Cao,Dean Tjosvold

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2010.00974.x

IF: 10.5

2011-01-01

Journal of Management Studies

Abstract:This study develops a model in which transformational leadership affects team coordination and performance through the conflict management approaches adopted by team members. Data were collected from three different sources in a lagged design from 108 teams in a large enterprise in China. Results support the reasoning that transformational leadership promotes team coordination and thereby team performance by encouraging teams to adopt a cooperative, as opposed to competitive, approach to conflict management. These results suggest that transformational leadership may help team members manage conflicts for their mutual benefit. This is an important mechanism through which transformational leadership enhances team coordination and, in turn, achieves higher team performance.
Divergent effects of transformational leadership on safety compliance: A dual-path moderated mediation model

Ting Wu,Yi Wang,Rebecca Ruan,Jianzhuang Zheng,Ting Wu,Yi Wang,Rebecca Ruan,Jianzhuang Zheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0262394

IF: 3.7

2022-01-24

PLoS ONE

Abstract:Research on the relationship between transformational leadership and safety compliance has yielded equivocal results. This study investigates how and when transformational leadership produces divergent effects on safety compliance. Using a time-lagged research design, we collect data from a sample of 309 employees in the Chinese construction industry to examine the hypothesized relationship. We find that transformational leadership positively affects safety compliance through employees’ felt obligation toward their leader. However, transformational leadership also negatively impacts safety compliance through safety risk tolerance. We further show that employees’ perception of the safety climate plays a contingent role in the above processes. Specifically, a high-level perceived safety climate strengthens the positive indirect effect of transformational leadership on safety compliance through felt obligation, while a low-level perceived safety climate strengthens the negative indirect effect of transformational leadership on safety compliance through safety risk tolerance. The theoretical and practical implications of the findings are also discussed.

multidisciplinary sciences
Leadership Styles and Employees’ Job-Related Attitudes: an Empirical Study on the Mediating Effects of Reciprocity and Trust

Jia Liangding,Song Jiwen,Li Chaoping,Cui Rongjun,Chen Yongxia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11782-007-0033-9

2007-01-01

Frontiers of Business Research in China

Abstract:Reciprocity and trust are the basic principles of human social exchanges. Using a sample of 972 managers in China, we examined the relationship between transformational and transactional leadership styles and job-related attitudes of employees, as well as the mediating effects of both reciprocity and trust on the above relationship based on social exchange theory. The main findings of structural equation modeling analyses were shown as follows. Firstly, transformational leadership not only affects organizational trust and commitment directly, but also motivates organizational trust of employees through the mediation of generalized and balanced reciprocity indirectly, and thus enhances organizational commitment and stay intention of employees. Secondly, transactional leadership indirectly affects organizational trust and commitment of employees through the mediation of reciprocity. Thirdly, generalized reciprocity has direct effects on organizational commitment of employees, whereas balanced reciprocity exerts its influences through affecting organizational trust of employees. Managerial suggestions are provided.
Psychological Capital As a Mediator of the Relationship Between Transformational Leadership and Followers' Task Performance and Organizational Commitment

LI Lei,SHANG Yufan,XI Youmin,WANG Yagang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2012.05.008

2012-01-01

Abstract:This paper develops a model in which psychological capital mediates the relationship between transformational leadership behavior and followers' task performance and organizational commitment.Based on a sample of 230 MBA students in China and by using structural equation modeling,this paper examines the specific relations among different dimensions of transformational leadership,followers' task performance,organizational commitment and psychological capital.This results show that three dimensions of psychological capital,self-efficacy,hope and resilience mediate the relationship between transformational leadership and task performance;and that self-efficacy and resilience mediate the relationship between transformational leadership and organizational commitment.Implications for the theory and practice of leadership are discussed,and future research directions are offered.
Impact of Transformational Leadership on System Exploration in the Mandatory Organizational Context.

Xixi Li,J. J. Po-An Hsieh

2007-01-01

Abstract:Organizational investments in such complex information systems as customer relationship management (CRM) systems have reached a record high. Unfortunately, underutilization of these sophisticated technologies hinders organizations from realizing the promised returns on investment. This study tackles this issue from the perspective of intention to explore, which refers to individual intentions to explore the technology and seek new ways of using it. Drawing upon insights from concepts of exploration, extra-role behavior, technology acceptance, and transformational leadership, this paper proposes a research model for employees' intention to explore in mandatory organizational contexts, with special emphasis on the effect of transformational leadership. The model was examined in a large telecom service company that uses CRM information systems. The results suggest that transformational leadership, intrinsic motivation, and extrinsic motivation (i.e. perceived usefulness) directly affect employees' exploratory intentions. Transformational leadership also indirectly influences intention to explore through individuals' intrinsic motivation and computer self-efficacy.
Notice of Retraction: Trust As a Mediator of the Effects of Transformational Leadership on Performance in Virtual Teams

Lei Wang,Youmin Xi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/wicom.2007.1484

2007-01-01

Abstract:This study examines the effects of transformational and transactional leadership on team member's performance in virtual teams. Trust in leader acts as an important mediator of the effects of transformational leadership on performance. Fifty-three, four-person teams participated in a laboratory study. Results showed the direct and indirect effects of transformational leadership and challenged the assumption about effects of transactional leadership in virtual teams.

The Validity of Transformational and Transactional Leadership Model

How Transformational Leadership Affects Teacher Collective Efficacy? the Mediating Role of Professional Learning Communities and the Moderating Role of Trust

An Empirical Study of the Female Entrepreneur Leadership Model in China

The Study of Effectiveness Conversion of Cross-Cultural Leadership Modes in Major Developmental Phases of International Enterprises

Transformational and Transactional Leadership: A Meta-Analytic Test of Their Relative Validity.

For the Good or the Bad? Interactive Effects of Transformational Leadership with Moral and Authoritarian Leadership Behaviors

Leadership in the Transformation:The summary and comment of transformational leadership theory

Transformational Leadership and Employees’ Reactions to Organizational Change: Evidence From a Meta-Analysis

Empirical Study on Transformational Leadership, Organizational Commitment and Turnover Intention in Chinese Context

The Impact of Transformational Leadership and Transactional Leadership on Voice Behavior and Creative Behavior through Job Crafting

Leader-Member Exchange As A,Mediator of the Relationship Between Transformational Leadership and Followers' Performance and Organizational Citizenship Behavior

The antecedents and outcomes of transformational leadership: leader's self-transcendent value, follower's environmental commitment and behavior

The Impact Of Transformational Leadership On Feedback Seeking Behavior

Transformational Leadership and Perceived Overqualification: A Career Development Perspective

Transactional Leadership and Organizational Learning Process

Linking Transformational Leadership and Team Performance: A Conflict Management Approach

Divergent effects of transformational leadership on safety compliance: A dual-path moderated mediation model

Leadership Styles and Employees’ Job-Related Attitudes: an Empirical Study on the Mediating Effects of Reciprocity and Trust

Psychological Capital As a Mediator of the Relationship Between Transformational Leadership and Followers' Task Performance and Organizational Commitment

Impact of Transformational Leadership on System Exploration in the Mandatory Organizational Context.

Notice of Retraction: Trust As a Mediator of the Effects of Transformational Leadership on Performance in Virtual Teams