Abstract:The desire to create more complex visual scenes in modern flight simulators outpaces recent increases in processor speed. As a result, the simulation transport delay remains a problem. Because of the limitations shown in the three prominent existing delay compensators—the lead/lag filter, the McFarland compensator and the Sobiski/Cardullo predictor—new approaches of compensating the transport delay in a flight simulator have been developed. The first novel compensator is the adaptive predictor making use of the Kalman filter algorithm in a unique manner so that the predictor can provide accurately the desired amount of prediction, significantly reducing the large spikes caused by the McFarland predictor. Among several simplified online adaptive predictors it illustrates mathematically why the stochastic approximation algorithm achieves the best compensation results. A second novel approach employed a reference aircraft dynamics model to implement a state space predictor on a flight simulator. The practical implementation formed the filter state vector from the operator's control input and the aircraft states. The relationship between the reference model and the compensator performance was investigated in great detail, and the best performing reference model was selected for implementation in the final tests. Piloted simulation tests were conducted for assessing the effectiveness of the two novel compensators in comparison to the McFarland predictor and no compensation. Thirteen pilots with heterogeneous flight experience executed straight-in and offset approaches, at various delay configurations, on a flight simulator where different predictors were applied to compensate for transport delay. Four metrics—the glide slope and touchdown errors, power spectral density of the pilot control inputs, NASA Task Load Index, and Cooper-Harper rating on the handling qualities—were employed for the analyses. The overall analyses show that while the adaptive predictor results in slightly poorer compensation for short added delay (up to 48 ms) and better compensation for long added delay (up to 192 ms) than the McFarland compensator, the state space predictor is fairly superior for short delay and significantly superior for long delay to the McFarland compensator. The state space predictor also achieves better compensation than the adaptive predictor. The results of the evaluation on the effectiveness of these predictors in the piloted tests agree with those in the theoretical offline tests conducted with the recorded simulation aircraft states.

New Predictive Filters for Compensating the Transport Delay on a Flight Simulator

Advanced Techniques for Mitigating the Effects of Temporal Distortions in Human in the Loop Control Systems

A Comprehensive Study of Three Delay Compensation Algorithms for Flight Simulators

Model Predictive Control with Fractional-Order Delay Compensation for Fast Sampling Systems

Transport Delay Compensation Algorithm for Simulator Based on Kalman Filter and Stochastic Approximation Algorithm

A Modified State Space Predictor by Optimal Control Model for Flight Simulator Transport Delay

The Results of a Simulator Study to Determine the Effects on Pilot Performance of Two Different Motion Cueing Algorithms and Various Delays, Compensated and Uncompensated

The Delay Kalman Filter Algorithm in Compound Control for TV Tracking Systems

Unscented Kalman Filter-Based Two-Stage Adaptive Compensation Method for Real-Time Hybrid Simulation

An Adaptive Delay Compensation Method Based on a Discrete System Model for Real-Time Hybrid Simulation

Observer-based Compensator Design for Networked Control Systems with Long Time Delays

Delay-dependent finite-time H∞ filtering for networked control systems: A switched system approach

Target Tracking For Visual Servoing Systems Based On An Adaptive Kalman Filter

Adaptive Kalman Filter Based Maneuvering Target Tracking

Analysis of Delay Compensation in Real-Time Dynamic Hybrid Testing with Large Integration Time-Step

Path Tracking Control Algorithm Considering Delay Compensation

Smith Predictor Compensation and Fuzzy Incremental Control for Delay of Space Docking Hardware-in-the-loop Simulation System

Preview Path Tracking Control with Delay Compensation for Autonomous Vehicles

A Delay Compensation Approach For Hardware-In-The-Loop Simulation Of Space Collision

Distributed Delay Compensation for a Hybrid Simulation System of Space Manipulator Capture

Comprehensive Predictive Control Method for Automated Vehicles With Delays.