Abstract:There are distinct Eastern and Western approaches that shape the conservation and interpretation of cultural heritage landscapes. While existing literature assesses each approach individually, there is limited research exploring potential for cross-cultural exchange and innovation to inform a more holistic conservation of heritage landscape sites. Using Chinese (representative of Eastern) and English (representative of Western) approaches as archetypal cases, and underpinned by a phenomenological ontological perspective, this theoretical contribution firstly establishes key distinctions between Chinese and English approaches toward heritage landscapes by conducting a review of relevant sources. Differences are subsequently synthesized into a comprehensive framework that supports a cultural convergence of approaches toward heritage landscapes. Informed by the literature, six key differences in approach are identified: (i) Philosophical underpinnings; (ii) spiritual and artistic emphasis; (iii) holistic and individual attitudes; (iv) concerns of continuity and evolution; (v) approaches toward community involvement; and (vi) relationship between nature, spirituality, and human-centricity. After reviewing these differences, a holistic framework is proposed that is underpinned by four key elements which have the capacity to overcome the differences identified: (i) harmonizing spirituality and esthetics; (ii) balancing continuity and evolution; (iii) fostering inclusive stewardship between communities and practitioners; and (iv) cultivating equilibrium between people and nature. The study concludes that this framework – what is termed a “cultural convergence” – can support more effective conservation of landscape sites, by capturing a broader cultural spectrum of heritage principles and concerns. The proposed framework opens avenues for cross-cultural exchange and advancement of more holistic heritage conservation strategies within an increasingly globalized heritage context. Future research should seek to apply this framework to the contemporary conservation of distinct heritage case study sites of interest to further advance research on this topic.

Conservation of Chinese Cultural Heritage during the 30 Years Past

Heritage Values and Its Conservation

NEW CHALLENGES OF WORLD HERITAGE CONSERVATION:CULTURAL LANDSCAPE

Cultural Heritage Conservation in the Perspective of Management

Tsinghua University-National Heritage Center

Study Progress of World Heritage Sites in the Past 22 Years——Based on 13 Chinese Journals

Retrospect and Prospect:Protection and Management of World Natural and Mixed Heritage in China

Conservation of the Heritage Network of Chinese Historic Cities

Thinking of Establishing the Integrated Conservation Network for Natural and Cultural Heritage Sites of China

Conservation during excavation: The current situation in China

Cultural convergence in heritage landscape conservation: A comparative study of Chinese and English traditions

A Comparative Study of the Conservation and Transmission of Cultural Heritage in China and Abroad--Dunhuang and Italy as Examples

The heritagization of cultural politics: anthropological research on Chinese cultural heritage

Discussing on Cultural Landscape Heritage and Its Landscape Culture's Conservation

ON THE CONCEPT OF HERITAGE AND THE SYSTEM OF HERITAGE CONSERVATION IN THE CONTEMPORARY WORLD AND CHINA

Heritage Conservation: Cultural Landscapes and American Landscape Architecture

Public Participation in Cultural Heritage Protection

Initial Exploration of Chinese Industrial Heritage

The Cultural Heritage Protection and Cultural Innovation in the Construction of New Countryside

Change and Continuity in the Recent 30 Years of Research on Modern Chinese History: Some Unsystematic Reflective Thoughts

THE RESEARCH STATUS OF INDUSTRIAL HERITAGE IN CHINA