Modification of the Sm-Nd isotopic system in garnet induced by retrogressive fluids
Shi-Chao An,Shuguang Li,Zhen Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jmg.12426
IF: 3.4
2018-01-01
Journal of Metamorphic Geology
Abstract:Garnet, as a major constitutive mineral of eclogite, is important for Sm-Nd dating of eclogite due to its high Sm/Nd ratio and its stability during retrogression. However, a comprehensive study of the petrography, mineral chemistry, garnet water content, and Sm-Nd isotopic composition of eclogites from the Bixiling massif, Central Dabie Zone (CDZ), reveals significant modification of the Sm-Nd isotopic system in garnet as a result of retrogression. This problem constitutes a challenge for Sm-Nd dating of the Bixiling eclogites, with the Sm-Nd isochron ages of 218 +/- 4 to 210 +/- 9Ma reported in the literature being younger than 226 +/- 3Ma, which is the generally accepted peak metamorphic age of the CDZ. Petrographic analysis reveals heterogeneity in colour within single fractured garnet grains. There are light-pink garnet (Grt-P) and red garnet (Grt-R) types that possess distinct chemical compositions. Compared to Grt-P, Grt-R has higher Fe and andradrite contents but lower Al and grossular contents. Grt-P also has lower water contents (15-35ppm) than Grt-R (34-65ppm), which, together with the spatial association between Grt-R and fractures, suggests that the colour change is related to fluid alteration. Grt-P is an ultra-high-pressure (UHP) mineral, and Grt-R is the product of the interaction between Grt-P and a fluid during retrogression. Moreover, Grt-R features lower Sm and Nd contents but higher Sm/Nd ratios than Grt-P. The Sm-Nd isochrons defined by UHP minerals (Grt-P+Omp+Rt or Grt-P+Cpx+WR) from three eclogite samples yield consistent ages of 226.0 +/- 3.8Ma, 225.0 +/- 3.9Ma and 226.2 +/- 6.9Ma, which are identical to the peak metamorphic age of 226 +/- 3Ma for the CDZ. The retrogressed garnet (i.e., Grt-R), omphacite and rutile, together define a pseudoisochron with younger ages of 218.9 +/- 5.9 to 202.8 +/- 4.8Ma, which are geologically meaningless. The increase in the Sm/Nd ratio with constant or lower Nd-143/Nd-144 ratios during the transformation of Grt-P to Grt-R was probably the cause of these younger ages.