Spinal cord atrophy-like changes in adolescent Chiari malformation type I patients: a neglected imaging change
何中,马鸿儒,秦晓东,蒋军,李文博,陈熙璞,蔡振宁,邱勇,朱泽章
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.cn121113-20210202-00105
2021-01-01
Abstract:Abstract:To compare the morphology of spinal cord between healthy adolescents with adolescent Chiari malformation type I (CMI) patients and investigate the impact of syringomyelia on the morphology of spinal cord in CMI patients.Methods:The clinical and radiological data of 292 CMI patients diagnosed by our center between June 2012 and March 2019 were retrospectively reviewed. Among them 15 CMI patients without syringomyelia were recruited in the CM group. Among the remaining 277 CMI patients, 274 patients had syringomyelia below the C
3-4 intervertebral disc. According to the principle of best matching, CMI patients with syringomyelia were selected with the closest age to the CM group (±18 months), and 30 CMI patients with syringomyelia were included in the CMS group according to a ratio of 1∶2. Thirty healthy adolescents were enrolled as the control group (NC group) in the same way. The anteroposterior diameters of spinal cord at C
2 (DSCO-C
2), spinal canal at C
2 (DSCA-C
2), midbrain-pontine junction (DPJ), the distance between the tip of cerebellar tonsils and the foramen magnum (AB) and the maximal diameter of the syrinx (D-syrinx) were measured on MRI. All radiographic parameters were measured twice independently by two spine surgeons, and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) were determined to demonstrate intra- and inter-observer reliability. One-way ANOVA and SNK-
q test were used to compare the above radiographic parameters and age between CM, CMS and NC group. The distribution of genders was compared between the three groups using Chi-square tests. Pearson correlation analysis were conducted to demonstrate the relationship between radiographic parameters in CM and CMS group.
Results:ICC ranged between 0.91 and 0.95 in the current study, demonstrating "excellent" reliability of radiographic measurements. No significant difference was noted regarding age and the distribution of genders among the three groups. Patients in CM and CMS groups showed similar DSCO-C
2 values (
P=0.254), both of which were significantly lower than that in NC group (
P<0.001). DSCA-C
2 in CMS group was significantly larger than that in CM (
P=0.003) and NC (
P<0.001) groups, while no significant difference was found between the CM and NC groups (
P=0.216). Moreover, DPJ in CMS group was significantly lower than that in CM group (
P<0.001) and NC group (
P<0.001). There was no significant difference in AB between CM and CMS groups (
P=0.948). DSCO-C
2 was significantly positively correlated with DSCA-C
2 in CMS group (
r=0.906,
P<0.001), while AB, D-syrinx, DSCO-syrinx, DSCA-syrinx and DPJ were not significantly correlated with DSCA-C
2. There were significant correlations observed between DPJ and other radiographic parameters in the CMS group (all
P>0.05). Significant positive correlation between DSCO-C
2 and DPJ was observed in CM group (
r=0.703,
P=0.005). There was no significant correlation between DSCO-C
2 and DSCA-C
2 and DPJ in NC group (all
P>0.05).
Conclusion:CMI adolescents have significant atrophic change of cervical spinal cord and midbrain-pontine junction compared with healthy adolescents, regardless of the existence of syrinx. Moreover, syrinx in CMI patients indicated more obvious atrophic change of midbrain-pontine junction and dilated spinal canal compared with isolated CMI patients.