An assessment of programs to promote improved household stoves in China

Jonathan E. Sinton,Kirk R. Smith,John W. Peabody,Liu Yaping,Zhang Xiliang,Rufus Edwards,G QUAN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0973-0826(08)60465-2

IF: 5.655

2004-01-01

Energy for Sustainable Development

Abstract:In 2002, a team of US and Chinese researchers collaborated on an independent, multidisciplinary review of China's improved rural household stove programs that have been carried out since the 1980s. The objectives were to delineate and evaluate the methods used to promote improved stoves, to as sess the development of commercial stove production and marketing organizations, and to measure the household impacts of the programs through surveys of health, stoves, and indoor air quality. The team found that China implemented broadly successful programs that delivered better stoves to a majority of households in targeted counties. That success was based on strong administrative, technical, and outreach competence and resources situated at the local level, motivated by sustained national-level attention. Despite overstated claims for penetration of improved stoves, most biomass stoves now in use have flues and other ''improved'' aspects, although field efficiencies are less than design efficiencies. However, most coal stoves, even those using improved fuel (briquettes), lack flues and cannot be considered improved. While in most areas ''improved'' stove technology became ''conventional'', some areas remain significant exceptions and re- quire intervention. Large roles for government oversight of quality control and support of R&D remain inadequately fulfilled. Most results of indoor air quality monitoring and health surveys were not clear-cut, in part because of the wide variety of fuel and stove combinations used by households. For nearly all household stove/fuel groupings, however, PM4 levels were higher than -- and sometimes more than twice as high as -- the national standard for indoor air (150 μ μg PM10/m3). If these results are typical, then a large fraction of China's rural population is now chronically exposed to levels of pollution far higher than those determined by the Chinese government to harm human health. Improved stoves in the surveyed households did result in reduced PM4 concentrations indoors for biomass fuel combinations. Coal use was associated with elevated levels of CO in exhaled breath, and improved biomass stoves with lower levels. Childhood asthma and adult respiratory disease were positively associated with coal use and negatively associated with improved stoves and good stove maintenance. The benefits of using improved biomass stoves can be out - weighed by the use of portable coal stoves without flues. Evaluation of the programs provides important lessons for future initiatives in China and in other countries.