The Third Dimension of Power Sources——the Empirical Study on"Relational Power"

Shang Yufan,Fu PingPing

2011-01-01

Abstract:Power literature has been dominated by the typology proposed by French and Raven (1959), which consisted of five types of power bases (Expert, Referent, Legitimate, Reward and Coercive) or two types (Personal versus Positional) as many studies used. However, Fu and Liu (2008) argued that these two types did not reflect the source of power originated from personal relationship, i.e., guanxi in China, and proposed to add "relational power" to the typology. Using multiple samples of Chinese employees, we first conducted in-depth interviews to understand the nature of relational power; and then empirically tested the existence of the power source. Results showed that: (1) the "relational power" existed as an additional type of source; (2) the basic types of "Guanxi" include those by blood, by common ground (school, hometown, work, etc.); (3) the effect of relational power is more obvious where the formal organizational contracts were imperfect; and (4) relational power could produce positive or negative effects on organizations.