Initial Surgical Procedure Impact on Prognosis of Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma

WANG Sha-sha,LIN Yan-song,LIANG Jun,CHEN Ge,LI Tian-jun

2012-01-01

Abstract:OBJECTIVE:To analyze the prognosis of papillary thyroid carcinoma(PTC) impacted by initial surgical procedure.METHODS:A retrospective study of 445 patients(329 female,116 male;age:9-68,average age:43 yr)with PTC scheduled for 131I treatment after surgery was conducted.Patients with 1)distant metastasis;2)tumor size≥1 cm;3)tumor 1 cm with extra-capsule invasion or lymph node metastasis were enrolled.Patient's initial surgical procedure varied from total thyroidectomy to nodular dissection and was classified into G1 and G2 groups according to initial surgical procedure adequate or not.Univariate and multivariate analysis of prognostic and tumor-related variables such as:age,gender,initial surgical procedure et al were performed.The self-rating anxiety and depression scales and the economic cost of patients influenced by surgery were also analyzed.RESULTS: Poor prognostic variables were extra-capsule invasion(P=0.001),the frequency of surgery(P0.001),the initial operation pattern(P0.001) by univariate analysis. The frequency of surgery(P0.001) and extra-capsule invasion(P=0.001) were the independent poor prognostic variable by multivariate analysis.Recurrence rate of G2 group were significantly higher than that of G1 group in their follow-up over 3 months,1 year,5 years,10 years,respectively(31.8%/14.1%,χ20.4y=4.49;59.1%/19.6%,χ21y=15.14;63.6%/23.5%,χ25y=13.96;71.2%/26.1%,χ210y=16.47;P0.05).The self-rating anxiety scale(SAS):the average score of G1,G2 was(37.5±8.0) and(40.6±11.26) ponits which were higher than the score of normal Chinese adults(tG1=6.037,tG2=7.068,P0.05),moreover,the SAS score of G2 was significantly higher than that of G1(t=0.534,P=0.000).The self-rating depression scale(SDS):G1 and G2 groups average score were(43.31±10.38) and(46.85 ± 11.86) ponits which were also higher than score of normal Chinese adults(tG1=5.974,tG2=6.466,P0.05).There was a statistical difference between G1 and G2(t=2.574,P=0.017).Re-operation induced by inadequate initial surgery resulted in the additional burden of at least 7 228 RMB on average of each patient,which is 1.8 times than that of every patient who received only one operation(t=6.537,P=0.000).CONCLUSIONS:Initial surgery is a vital factor for the prognosis of PTC.Patients with 1)distant metastasis;2)tumor size≥1 cm;3)tumor 1 cm with extra-capsule invasion or lymph node metastasis should treat total thyroidectomy or near-total thyroidectomy.Inadequate initial surgical procedure causes poor prognosis and have higher recurrence rate as well as added both mental and economic burden to the patients.