Abstract:Background: In Japan, people are negative towards life-prolonging treatments. Laws that regulate withholding or discontinuing life-prolonging treatments and advance directives do not exist. Physicians, however, view discontinuing life-prolonging treatments negatively due to fears of police investigations. Although ministerial guidelines were announced regarding the decision process for end-of-life care in 2007, a consensus could not be reached on the definition of end-of-life and conditions for withholding treatment. We established a forum for extended discussions and consensus building on this topic. Methods: We used the Neo-Socratic Dialogue (NSD) method which promotes philosophical discussion based on a case-study to address a question and formulate a consensus and answer in a group. The question chosen for the dialogue was: "What is a life-prolonging treatment?" A series of dialogues took place over a period of one and a half days. It was carried out by three groups in 2010 and 2011. Seven participants with diverse backgrounds were recruited per group. We analyzed the content of the discussion. Results: Based on three case studies concerning different opinions about treatment options for an older dementia patient, a patient demanding chemotherapy, and a severely ill neonate, conditions for futile life-prolonging treatment were elucidated through NSD. Such treatments are those carried out for the sole purpose of prolonging life and are detrimental to the patient, and should be decided based foremost on the patient's lack of desire for treatment, the consensus of those involved, and through social acceptance. These arguments are essentially consistent with ones on medical futility in the United States. By expressing the objective of healthcare and the requirement of social acceptance, participants were also able to elucidate issues related to the awareness of those involved and the medical environment. Compared to the end-of-life guidelines in Japan, the objective of treatment, its effects, and benefits were more specifically discussed with the patient's intentions as the foremost consideration, rather than being limited to the terminal stage. Conclusions: This small study contributed to elucidating the conditions and current problems of futile life-prolonging treatment through NSD. They would suggest more substantial guidelines and improvements on the administration of the treatment.

Ethical Reflections on Life Maintenance Therapy among Patients with Terminal Diseases

Humanity behind the intention of primary caregiver to choose withdrawing life-sustaining treatment for terminating patients

End of Life: Care Ethical Perspectives

Is there too much care in advanced cancer?

End-of-life medical treatment of older cardiac patients

Ethical Confusion Caused By Withdrawing Treatment of Malignant Tumors of The Last Stage

Expert Consensus on Maintenance Treatment for Metastatic Colorectal Cancer in China.

Terminal Care and the Value of Life Near its End

Quality of Life and Management Project for Patients with Advanced Lung Cancer

Analysis of the Necessity and Modalities of Imparting Death Education to Medical Students Undergoing Training in Oncology Departments

Qualitative Analysis of Family Members' Decision Making on Treatment and Resuscitation of Terminal Stage Advanced Cancer Patients

Palliative Care Approach to Chronic Diseases: End Stages of Heart Failure, Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, Liver Failure, and Renal Failure

Self-care towards the end of life: A systematic review and narrative synthesis on access, quality and cost

Defining futile life-prolonging treatments through Neo-Socratic Dialogue

Moral Distress Amongst American Physician Trainees Regarding Futile Treatments at the End of Life: A Qualitative Study

Communication and Decision Making About Life-Sustaining Treatment: Examining the Experiences of Resident Physicians and Seriously-Ill Hospitalized Patients

[Opinions on the Prevention and Treatment of Chronic Critical Illness].

Navigating tensions when life‐sustaining treatment is withdrawn: A thematic synthesis of nurses' and physicians' experiences

Life-Sustaining Treatments Among Medicare Beneficiaries with and without Dementia at the End of Life

Timely dying in dementia: Use patients' judgments and broaden the concept of suffering

Critical care nurses' experiences of ethical challenges in end-of-life care