Abstract:Objectives The aim of this systematic review was to synthesize research completed between 2011 and 2021 to report the current state of the science on the use of standardized patients (SPs) to teach communication skills. The research question that guided this study was, “Among health care professionals, does the use of SP methodology as a means of teaching communication skills result in improved learner knowledge, skills, attitudes, and/or patient outcomes when compared with other simulation methodologies?” Design This review was reported in line with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA). Data Sources Four databases (CINAHL, Ovid Embase, Ovid Medline, and Scopus) were searched using a combination of medical subject headings, or Mesh terms, as well as keywords to retrieve nonindexed citations. Review Methods The inclusion criteria were broad to complete a comprehensive search of the literature. To be eligible for inclusion, a study had to be original research that compared simulation using an SP to another simulation methodology. The study had to evaluate communication knowledge, skill, attitude, and/or patient outcome with an academic or practicing health care professional. Results The initial database search strategy yielded 8058 citations. These results were narrowed down to 18 studies through an in-depth analysis of each article using identified inclusion criteria. The SPs were superior to role play in 1 (33%, n = 3) study where knowledge was evaluated, 6 (75%, n = 8) studies where skills were evaluated, and 1 (20%, n = 5) study where attitude was evaluated. The SPs were compared with a manikin in 5 studies. The SPs were superior to a manikin in 3 (60%, n = 5) studies where knowledge was measured and in 1 (100%, n = 1) study where attitude was measured. No study measured the outcome knowledge of an SP to a manikin. Finally, SPs were compared with a virtual SP in 3 studies. When knowledge was evaluated, SPs were superior to a virtual SP in 1 study (100%, n = 1). When skills were evaluated, SPs were superior to a virtual SP in 1 study (50%, n = 2), and when attitude was evaluated, SPs were superior to a virtual SP in no study (0%, n = 2). No study evaluated patient outcomes in the comparison of an SP to another simulation methodology. Conclusions Studies show a weak indication that SP-based education is superior to other simulation methodologies in most contexts. However more rigorous studies with larger sample sizes, validated instruments, and effects on patient outcomes are needed to definitively determine the optimal method/modality for teaching communication to health care professionals.

Evaluation of the validity of standardized patients on clinical communication skills training

Application of Standardized Patients in Intensive Training of Clinical Skills for General Practice Trainees and Its Effectiveness

Applying standardized patients to augment clinical skills in clinical medical students’ national proficiency test

Application of standardized patients in training of communication skills in consultation for resident general practitioners

Standardized Patients in Assessment for Clinical Competencies of Trainees in General Practice Training

Improving the communication skills of medical students --A survey of simulated patient-based learning in Chinese medical universities

Exploration of Standardized Patients in the Assessment of Doctor-Patient Communication on 8-Year Program Medical Students

The Clinical Communication Skills Course and Self-Assessments for Medical Students

What Do We Need to Improve Communication Skills Training in China: Suggestions from Nationwide Survey

Training and Assessment of Doctor-patient Communication Skills:Establishment of An Efficient Mode

Assessment of Clinical Communication Skills of Medical Students Through the Simulated Patient Approach

The Use of Standardized Patients to Teach Communication Skills—A Systematic Review

Impact of SP's Oral Feedback on Performances of Medical Students in OSCE

Evaluation of Medical Students' Doctor-patient Communication Capacity Based on Community Environment

Application of students standardized patient in teaching and assessment of physical examination skills

Comparison Between Impact of Standardized Patient's Oral Feedback and Self-Evaluation on Performances of Medical Students in Objective Structured Clinical Examination

Analysis of Influential Factors on Using Standardized Patients to Assess General Practice Trainees' Clinical Competences of

Comparing Research of Doctor-Patient Communication Between Residents under Standardized Training and Eight-Year Medical Students: an Example of Peking Union Medical College

Assessment of clinical competency among TCM medical students using standardized patients of traditional Chinese medicine: A 5-year prospective randomized study

Effectiveness of a modified doctor-patient communication training Programme designed for surgical residents in China: a prospective, large-volume study at a single Centre

Effectiveness of clinical scenario dramas to teach doctor-patient relationship and communication skills