The Action of Propofol Depressing the Stress Reaction During the Operation Compere with Sevoflurane: A Meta-analysis
方吉,殷霞丽,张立,马正良
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13286/j.cnki.chinhosppharmacyj.2013.07.021
2013-01-01
Abstract:OBJECTIVE To evaluate the effectiveness of propofol depressing the stress reaction during the operation compared with sevoflurane.METHODS We searched PubMed(1990 to 2012),OVID(1990 to 2012),EBSCO(1990 to 2012),The Cochrane Library(2000 to 2012),Wangfang Date(1990 to 2012),and CNKI(1990 to 2012) databases to identify randomized controlled trials(RCTs) that compared propofol and sevoflurane for depressing the stress reaction during the operation.The quality of the included RCTs was evaluated by two reviewers independently,and Meta-analysis was performed by RevMan 4.2 software.RESULTS Four RCTs were included.The methodological quality of them were all poor.Among the four RCTs,95 patients received propofol and 95 received sevoflurane.The results of Meta-analyses showed that the average heart rate during the operation had significantly difference between two groups [(WMD=-2.91,95%CI(-8.19,-0.34),P=0.68],the average heart rate in the post-operation also had significantly difference[(WMD=-10.49,95%CI(-14.44,-6.54),P=0.000 02],the arterial puressure during the operation had significant difference [(WMD=-3.47,95%CI(0.17,6.77),P=0.64],the mean arterial puressure during the post-operation had no significant difference [(WMD=-1.84,95%CI(-5.19,1.52),P=0.032],the concentration of cortisol in the blood plasma during the operation had significant difference[(WMD=-4.83,95%CI(-6.02,-3.64),P0.000 01],the concentration of cortisol in the blood plasma post the operation had significantly difference[(WMD=-12.24,95%CI(-23.58,-0.901),P0.000 01].CONCLUSION In the general anesthesia,sevoflurane had better effect to inhibit the blood puressure rising induced by the stress reaction which caused by the trauma than that of propofol.Propofol had better effect to decrease the cortisol excretion.So both of them can inhibit the stress reactions during the operation and post the operation.