Analysis on Environmental Policies of Trans-boundary Water Pollution Conflicts in China
WANG Xiao-yong,WAN Yu-qiu,JIANG Wen,ZHU Xiao-dong,MIAO Xu-bo,LI Yang-fan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-2104.2011.03.005
2011-01-01
China Population Resources and Environment
Abstract:Trans-boundary water pollution disputes have seriously affected the regional environment security and social stability.Serious trans-boundary conflicts over water pollution have continued under the traditional slice-intersect management mode.Although coordination mechanisms have not been established in our cross-regional(basin) water disputes,some deficiencies were found after many useful explorations and practices in many areas had been conducted.Water environmental pollution has trans-boundary effects that need to be tackled multilaterally.Trans-boundary water treaties are evaluated using Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis(MCDA) to identify the most desirable treaty and suggested how existing treaties can be improved.More specifically,a flexible MCDA technique,called the Elimination Method,has been employed to analyze and compare three multilateral treaties and two bilateral trans-boundary treaties according to three main criteria,a total of 11 standards at four scales: cross state,provincial,municipal and watershed borders.The analytical results reveal limitations of these water policies with respect to conflict resolutions: ①the management policies in the absence of effective legal procedural legislation at all spatial scales;②lack of legal protection and support mechanisms,ineffective implementation;③lack of effective organizations,legal procedures and solutions through consultation mechanisms in dispute settlement mechanisms.We provide directions for the possible improvement in disputes coordination mechanisms and provide technical and policy support.