Abstract:Objective To compare the effects of rib internal fixation and thoracic external fixation in treatment of traumatic flail chest. Methods Eighty six cases of traumatic flail chest with multiple injuries,admitted to hospital from January 2006 to June 2009 ,were recruited into the study and divided into rib internal fixation and thoracic external fixation groups randomly. The clinical data were analyzed retrospectively. Rib internal fixations with Ti-Ni shape memory alloy embracing connector were performed in internal-fixation group(n = 45) and thoracic external fixations were performed in external-fixation group(n = 41). The outcomes were compared between the two groups. Results No patient in internal-fixation group developed chest wall deformity,while 19 patients in external-fixation group had chest wall deformity left. The mean times of hospital stay([ 15. 1 ± 1.8]d vs [22. 9 ±2. 8]d,t = - 15. 724,P ＜0. 01) ,ICU stay([5.7 ± 1.5]d vs [ 14. 4 ±2. 9]d,t =- 17.711, P ＜ 0. 01), and mechanical ventilation([ 3.9 ± 1.5 ] d vs [ 1 1.6 ± 2. 3 ] d, t = - 17. 256, P ＜ 0. 01),in internal-fixation group were significantly shorter than those in external-fixation group. The occurrence rate of respiratory complications (including pulmonary inflammation and (or) atelectasis and (or) respiratory failure)in internal-fixation group was significantly lower than those in external-fixation group(35.6% vs. 70. 7% ,x2 =10.641,P ＜ 0.01). Followed-up data of three months after discharge showed that the pulmonary function parameters, such as total lung capacity([ 89. 5 ± 3. 1 ] % vs. [ 79. 1 ± 5. 1 ] %, t = 11. 705, P ＜ 0. 01), forced vital capacity([ 80. 2 ± 2. 8 ] % vs. [ 69. 8 ± 3. 8 ] % ,t = 14. 241 ,P ＜0. 01) ,forced expiratory volume in the 1st second ([74.8 ±4.4]% vs. [71.9 ±3.6]% ,t =3.201,P ＜0.01),peak expiratory flow ([82.8 ±4.4]%vs. [79. 8 ±4. 9]% ,t =2. 885,P ＜0. 01) and forced expiratory flows at 75% of the vital capacity( [68.2 ±2. 2] % vs. [61.9 ± 2. 9 ]%, t = 11. 286; P ＜ 0. 01) were significantly higher in internal-fixation group than those in external-fixation group. Conclusion Rib internal fixation for traumatic flail chest can quickly correct chest wall deformity, stabilize thoracis and eliminate paradoxical chest wall movement. Patients accepted this treatment have a shorter therapy process during the intensive care unit and hospital stay, less pulmonary complications. They also show less long-term restrictive pulmonary functions impairment, when compared to the patients in the thoracic external fixation group. Rib internal fixation with Ti-Ni shape memory alloy embracing connector is a simple and effective therapy.

Comparison of clinical treatment for severe trauma with flail chest

Comparative Study of Wound Outcomes and Surgical Strategies: Internal Fixation Versus External Stabilization in Rib Fracture Patients with Traumatic Chest Wounds.

To analyze the effect of the chest protection plate with mechanical ventilation in flail chest combined with pulmonary contusion

Comparison Between Surgical and Conservative Treatment for Flail Chest

Study on effect of surgical treatment on hemodynamics in patients with traumatic flail chest

Treatment of Traumatic Flail Chest in 54 Cases

Surgical internal fixation in the treatment of traumatic flail chest

Comparison of surgical fixation and nonsurgical management of flail chest and pulmonary contusion.

Damage Control Surgery for Treatment of Flail Chest Combined with Multiple Trauma

Effect of Early Mechanical Ventilation on the Treatment of Flail Chest Complicated with Acute Pulmonary Contusion

Comparative Study of Pressure-Control Ventilation and Volume-Control Ventilation in Treating Traumatic Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome.

Surgical versus conservative treatment of flail chest. Evaluation of the pulmonary status.

Retrospective Study on Staged Treatment of Long Bone Shaft Fractures with Severe Thoracic Trauma

Progress of the diagnosis and therapy for flail chest

Ventilatory Treatment of Flail Chest Together with Pulmonary Contusion

Rib internal fixation for traumatic flail chest

Curative effect of pressure dressing on chest wall,traction and internal fixation on pulmonary function in dogs with flail chest

Treatment of flail chest with Encircling rib bone connector in 90 cases

The Clinical Study of Rib Plate

Progress and Controversy in Management of Traumatic Flail Chest

Damage control surgery for patients with severe chest trauma