Effect of Postoperative Patient-Controlled Analgesia by Different Administration Routes on T-lymphocyte Subtypes and Natural Killer Cells of Blood in Patients with Esophageal Carcinoma

熊章荣,张在空,刘预,牟林,张智,蔡华荣,周洪,唐延先

2010-01-01

Abstract:Objective To investigate the effect of different postoperative patient-controlled analgesia on T-lymphocyte subtypes and natural killer cells of blood in esophageal cancer patients.Methods Sixty patients aged 50-65 years undergoing elective esophageal cancer surgery were randomly divided into three groups：patient controlled subcutaneous analgesia group （PCSA,n=20）,patient controlled intravenous analgesia group （PCIA,n=20）,patient controlled epidural analgesia group （PCEA,n=20）. VAS scores were measured at 6,12,18,24 and 48 h after operation respectively. Blood samples were collected before anesthesia（T1）,operation end（T2） and 1 d（T3）,2 d（T4）,5 d（T5） after surgery for determination of T-lymphocyte subsets （CD3＋,CD4＋,CD8＋,CD4＋/CD8＋,CD45＋） and NK cell by flow cytometry.Results Analgesic effect was observed in three groups,which VAS scores were within 3. Compared with baseline value,the level of CD3＋,CD4＋,CD8＋,NK cell decreased significantly at T3-T5 in three groups （P0.05 or P0.01）. From T4,the level of CD3＋,CD4＋,CD8＋ in PCEA group were uptrend,while downtrend in PCSA and PCIA groups. The level of T-lymphocyte subsets （CD3＋,CD4＋,CD8＋） in T5 were enhance in three groups,PCSA and PCIA groups were higher than PCEA. The ratio of CD4＋and CD8＋ in T4 and T5 were increase in both PCIA and PCSA groups; the ratio of CD4＋ and CD8＋ significantly increased in T4、T5 than in T1 in PCSA; the level of CD4＋and CD8＋ in T4 were lower in PCIA group compared with PCEA group （P0.05）.Conclusion PCSA,PCEA or PCIA can use analgesia for patients with esophageal cancer. Immune function of patients in PCEA group may recover earlier than in PCIA groups. There were similar immune protective effect in PCSA and PCEA groups.