Completeness of the Basic Logical System M for Default Reasoning

ZHOU Bei-hai,MAO Yi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-9841.2006.01.014

2006-01-01

Abstract:In this paper,we proved the completeness of system M with respect to the class of Γcanonical frames,on which Γ-canonical models are built.Given any finite set of formulas,Γ,a Γ-canonical frame is finite.The decidability of system M can thus be derived from the finite model property.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Some General Completeness Results for Propositionally Quantified Modal Logics

Yifeng Ding,Yipu Li

2024-06-23

Abstract:We study the completeness problem for propositionally quantified modal logics on quantifiable general frames, where the admissible sets are the propositions the quantifiers can range over and expressible sets of worlds are admissible, and Kripke frames, where the quantifiers range over all sets of worlds. We show that any normal propositionally quantified modal logic containing all instances of the Barcan scheme is strongly complete with respect to the class of quantifiable general frames validating it. We also provide a sufficient condition for the truth of all formulas, possibly with quantifiers, to be preserved under passing from a quantifiable general frame to its underlying Kripke frame. This is reminiscent of both the idea of elementary submodel in model theory and the persistence concepts in propositional modal logic. The key to this condition is the concept of finite diversity (Fritz 2023), and with it, we show that if $\Theta$ is a set of Sahlqvist formulas whose class of Kripke frames has finite diversity, then the smallest normal propositionally quantified modal logic containing $\Theta$, Barcan, a formula stating the existence of world propositions, and a formula stating the definability of successor sets, is Kripke complete. As a special case, we have a simple finite axiomatization of the logic of Euclidean Kripke frames.

Logic,Logic in Computer Science
A Base Logic for Default Reasoning

Zhou Beihai,Mao Yi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11466-006-0032-5

2006-01-01

Frontiers of Philosophy in China

Abstract:Based on a close study of benchmark examples in default reasoning, such as Nixon Diamond, Penguin Principle, etc., this paper provides an in depth analysis of the basic features of default reasoning. We formalize default inferences based on Modus Ponens for Default Implication, and mark the distinction between “local inferences” (to infer a conclusion from a subset of given premises) and “global inferences” (to infer a conclusion from the entire set of given premises). These conceptual analyses are captured by a formal semantics that is built upon the set-selection function technique. A minimal logic system M of default reasoning that accommodates Modus Ponens for Default Implication and suitable for local inferences is proposed, and its soundness is proved.
Going Forth and Drawing Back: an Intensional Approach in Nonmonotonic Inference.

Yi Mao,Beihai Zhou,Beishui Liao

2015-01-01

Abstract:We decompose a nonmonotonic inference Gamma (sic) alpha into two stages: going forth to deduce all default conclusions in a logic system named DC (short for Default Conclusions), and drawing back less preferable conclusions in the face of conflicting default conclusions, based on a binary "more preferable" relation defined on those subformulas of that are also its deductive consequences. Under the possible-world semantics framework, we construct a set selection function and build up a theory of semantics, as a variant of traditional selection function semantics. We prove that the underlying logic system DC is sound and complete with respect to set selection function semantics. Using this two-layer mechanism, we account for benchmark examples including the Nixon Diamond and the Penguin Principle.
Logic of Primary-Conditionals and Secondary-Conditionals

Liu Zhuanghu,Li Xiaowu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11466-006-0033-4

2006-01-01

Frontiers of Philosophy in China

Abstract:Firstly, the authors analyzed the properties of primary-onditionals and secondary-conditionals, establish the minimum system C2Lm of primary- conditionals and secondary-conditionals, and then prove some of the formal theorems of the system which have important intuitive meanings. Secondly, the authors constructed the neighborhood semantics, prove the soundness of C2Lm, introduce a general concept of canonical model by the neighborhood semantics, and then prove the completeness of C2Lm by the canonical model. Finally, according to the technical results of the minimum system C2Lm, the authors discuss some of the important problems concerning primary-conditionals and secondary-onditionals.
Completeness in local positive logic

Arturo Rodriguez Fanlo,Ori Segel

2024-04-26

Abstract:We develop the basic model theory of local positive logic, a new logic that mixes positive logic (where negation is not allowed) and local logic (where models omit types of infinite distant pairs). We study several basic model theoretic notions such as compactness, positive closedness (existential closedness) and completeness (irreducibility).

Logic
A logic for default reasoning

R. Reiter

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0004-3702(80)90014-4

IF: 14.4

1980-04-01

Artificial Intelligence

Abstract:The need to make default assumptions is frequently encountered in reasoning about incompletely specified worlds. Inferences sanctioned by default are best viewed as beliefs which may well be modified or rejected by subsequent observations. It is this property which leads to the non-monotonicity of any logic of defaults.In this paper we propose a logic for default reasoning. We then specialize our treatment to a very large class of commonly occuring defaults. For this class we develop a complete proof theory and show how to interface it with a top down resolution theorem prover. Finally, we provide criteria under which the revision of derived beliefs must be effected.

computer science, artificial intelligence
Arithmetical completeness for some extensions of the pure logic of necessitation

Haruka Kogure

2024-09-02

Abstract:We investigate the arithmetical completeness theorems of some extensions of Fitting, Marek, and Truszczyński's pure logic of necessitation $\mathbf{N}$. For $m,n \in \omega$, let $\mathbf{N}^+ \mathbf{A}_{m,n}$, which was introduced by Kurahashi and Sato, be the logic obtained from $\mathbf{N}$ by adding the axiom scheme $\Box^n A \to \Box^m A$ and the rule $\dfrac{\neg \Box A}{\neg \Box \Box A}$. In this paper, among other things, we prove that for each $m,n \geq 1$, the logic $\mathbf{N}^+ \mathbf{A}_{m,n}$ becomes a provability logic.

Logic
A Model of Reasoning about Knowledge

Ruqian Lu,Mingsheng Ying

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/bf02917028

1998-01-01

Science China Technological Sciences

Abstract:A modal logical language and its Kripke semantics and Aumann semantics are introduced. A complete formal deduction system is established to describe reasoning about knowledge in multi-agent systems involving different languages, and an institution of logics for multi-agent systems is constructed.
The Finite Model Property of Some Non-normal Modal Logics with the Transitivity Axiom

Kirill Kopnev

2023-05-15

Abstract:In 1997 Timothy J. Surendonk proved via algebraic semantics that all modal logics without iterative axioms are canonical and so strongly complete. In this paper, we continue the work done by Surendonk in this field. We use neighborhood semantics to show that some iterative logics (with the axiom $\Box p\rightarrow\Box\Box p$) are also strongly complete and have the finite model property.

Logic
On the local consequence of modal Product logic: standard completeness and decidability

Amanda Vidal

2023-06-24

Abstract:Modal extensions of Product fuzzy logic can be considered both over Kripke models whose accessibility relation is valued, and over Kripke models with classical accessibility relation. We study the local consequence of the previous two modal Product logics. We prove that these logics are standard complete, in the sense that the logic defined over Kripke models evaluated over all product algebras coincides with that defined over Kripke models evaluated over the standard product algebra (with universe [0,1]). This holds both for the logic over classical Kripke frames, and for that over frames with a valued accessibility relation. Second, we prove that the previous logics are decidable.

Logic,Computational Complexity
Axiomatizing modal inclusion logic and its variants

Aleksi Anttila,Matilda Häggblom,Fan Yang

2024-07-19

Abstract:We provide a complete axiomatization of modal inclusion logic - team-based modal logic extended with inclusion atoms. We review and refine an expressive completeness and normal form theorem for the logic, define a natural deduction proof system, and use the normal form to prove completeness of the axiomatization. Complete axiomatizations are also provided for two other extensions of modal logic with the same expressive power as modal inclusion logic: one augmented with a might operator and the other with a single-world variant of the might operator.

Logic
Incompleteness of boundedly axiomatizable theories

Ali Enayat,Albert Visser

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1090/proc/16975

IF: 0.9709

2024-09-21

Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society

Abstract:Our main result (Theorem A) shows the incompleteness of any consistent sequential theory T T formulated in a finite language such that T T is axiomatized by a collection of sentences of bounded quantifier-alternation-depth. Our proof employs an appropriate reduction mechanism to rule out the possibility of completeness by simply invoking Tarski's Undefinability of Truth theorem. We also use the proof strategy of Theorem A to obtain other incompleteness results.

mathematics, applied
The Logic of Correct Models

Juan Pablo Aguilera,Fedor Pakhomov

2024-02-23

Abstract:For each $n\in\mathbb{N}$, let $[n]\phi$ mean "the sentence $\phi$ is true in all $\Sigma_{n+1}$-correct transitive sets." Assuming G\"odel's axiom $V = L$, we prove the following graded variant of Solovay's completeness theorem: the set of formulas valid under this interpretation is precisely the set of theorems of the linear provability logic GLP.3. We also show that this result is not provable in ZFC, so the hypothesis V = L cannot be removed. As part of the proof, we derive (in ZFC) the following purely modal-logical results which are of independent interest: the logic GLP.3 coincides with the logic of closed substitutions of GLP, and is the maximal non-degenerate, normal extension of GLP.

Logic
Kripke-Completeness and Sequent Calculus for Quasi-Boolean Modal Logic

Minghui Ma,Juntong Guo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11225-024-10095-4

2024-03-07

Studia Logica

Abstract:Quasi-Boolean modal algebras are quasi-Boolean algebras with a modal operator satisfying the interaction axiom. Sequential quasi-Boolean modal logics and the relational semantics are introduced. Kripke-completeness for some quasi-Boolean modal logics is shown by the canonical model method. We show that every descriptive persistent quasi-Boolean modal logic is canonical. The finite model property of some quasi-Boolean modal logics is proved. A cut-free Gentzen sequent calculus for the minimal quasi-Boolean logic is developed and we show that it has the Craig interpolation property.

mathematics,logic
Completeness of two fragments of a logic for conditional strategic reasoning

Yinfeng Li,Fengkui Ju

2024-05-19

Abstract:Classical logics for strategic reasoning, such as Coalition Logic and Alternating-time Temporal Logic, formalize absolute strategic reasoning about the unconditional strategic abilities of agents to achieve their goals. Goranko and Ju introduced a logic ConStR for strategic reasoning about conditional strategic abilities. However, its completeness is still an open problem. ConStR has three featured operators, and one of them has the following reading: For some action of A that guarantees the achievement of her goal, B has an action to guarantee the achievement of his goal. The logic about this operator is called CConStR. In this paper, we prove completeness for two fragments of CConStR. The key notions of our proof approach include downward validity lemma, grafted models, and upward derivability lemma. The proof approach has good potential to be applied to the completeness of ConStR and other logics.

Logic in Computer Science
The finite frame property of some extensions of the pure logic of necessitation

Taishi Kurahashi,Yuta Sato

2024-06-19

Abstract:We study the finite frame property of some extensions of Fitting, Marek, and Truszczyński's pure logic of necessitation $\mathbf{N}$. For any natural numbers $m, n$, we introduce the logic $\mathbf{N}^+\mathbf{A}_{m, n}$ by adding the single axiom scheme $\Box^n \varphi \to \Box^m \varphi$ and the rule $\dfrac{\neg \Box \varphi}{\neg \Box \Box \varphi}$ (Ros$^\Box$) into $\mathbf{N}$. We prove the finite frame property of $\mathbf{N}^+\mathbf{A}_{m, n}$ with respect to Fitting, Marek, and Truszczyński's relational semantics. We also prove that for $n \ge 2$, the logic obtained by removing the rule Ros$^\Box$ from $\mathbf{N}^+\mathbf{A}_{0, n}$ is incomplete with respect to that semantics.

Logic
The Lattice of Sahlqvist Logics

Jiangjie Qiu,Beihai Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-3202.2009.01.003

2009-01-01

Abstract:Every Sahlqvist formula is an elementary complete one.If we take Sahlqvist formulae as addition axioms to the minimal normal modal logic K,we get a strong elementary logic,namely Sahlqvist logic.In this paper we discuss properties of the class of Sahlqvist logics S.It is closed under intersection and another set operation that can be looked upon as logical union,so that S forms a lattice.Let E denote the class of logics K(?)fin_(mn).It is easy to determine that E is a subclass of S.We can deduce that every K(?)fin_(mn) is a canonical logic,following from the Sahlqvist theorem.We can also get the same result by studying properties of the canonical frame of K(?)fin_(mn).E is an interesting subclass of S.It is a sublattice of S.It has a regular geometric form, in which there are infinite length chains,but every antichain in E is finite.Besides, the well known tabular logics are closely related to E,for every tabular logic is an extension of some K(?)fin_(mn).From the result that E has infinite length chains,we can easily know that S also has infinite length antichain.We can prove that in the class {K(?)~i□p→□(?)~ip|i<ω},every logic is not contained in others,so that this class is an infinite length antichain of S,which is different from the result of E.The incomplete degree is an important concept when we study logical lattices.Usually,it is not easy to study the incomplete degree problems.However,we can easily conclude that the incomplete degree of Sahlqvist logic respect to the lattice S is 1.
An $ω$-rule for the logic of provability and its models

Katsumi Sasaki,Yoshihito Tanaka

2023-11-02

Abstract:In this paper, we discuss a proof system $\mathsf{NGL}$ for the logic $\mathbf{GL}$ of provability, which is equipped with an $\omega$-rule. We show the three classes of transitive Kripke frames, the class which strongly validates the $\omega$-rule, the class which weakly validates the $\omega$-rule, and the class which is defined by the Löb formula, are mutually different, while all of them characterize $\mathbf{GL}$. This gives an example of a proof system $P$ and a class $C$ of Kripke frames such that $P$ is sound with respect to $C$ but the soundness cannot be proved by simple induction on the height of the derivations in $P$. We also show Kripke completeness of $\mathsf{NGL}$ in an algebraic manner. As a corollary, we show that the class of modal algebras which is defined by equations $\Box x\leq\Box\Box x$ and $\bigwedge_{n\in\omega}\Diamond^{n}1=0$ is not a variety.

Logic
Constructing Fully Complete Models of Multiplicative Linear Logic

Andrea Schalk,Hugh Paul Steele

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2168/LMCS-11%283%3A6%292015

2015-09-03

Abstract:The multiplicative fragment of Linear Logic is the formal system in this family with the best understood proof theory, and the categorical models which best capture this theory are the fully complete ones. We demonstrate how the Hyland-Tan double glueing construction produces such categories, either with or without units, when applied to any of a large family of degenerate models. This process explains as special cases a number of such models from the literature. In order to achieve this result, we develop a tensor calculus for compact closed categories with finite biproducts. We show how the combinatorial properties required for a fully complete model are obtained by this glueing construction adding to the structure already available from the original category.

Logic in Computer Science
Correspondence, Canonicity, and Model Theory for Monotonic Modal Logics

Kentarô Yamamoto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1904.12997

2020-02-13

Abstract:We investigate the role of coalgebraic predicate logic, a logic for neighborhood frames first proposed by Chang, in the study of monotonic modal logics. We prove analogues of the Goldblatt-Thomason Theorem and Fine's Canonicity Theorem for classes of monotonic neighborhood frames closed under elementary equivalence in coalgebraic predicate logic. The elementary equivalence here can be relativized to the classes of monotonic, quasi-filter, augmented quasi-filter, filter, or augmented filter neighborhood frames, respectively. The original, Kripke-semantic versions of the theorems follow as a special case concerning the classes of augmented filter neighborhood frames.

Logic

Completeness of the Basic Logical System M for Default Reasoning

Some General Completeness Results for Propositionally Quantified Modal Logics

A Base Logic for Default Reasoning

Going Forth and Drawing Back: an Intensional Approach in Nonmonotonic Inference.

Logic of Primary-Conditionals and Secondary-Conditionals

Completeness in local positive logic

A logic for default reasoning

Arithmetical completeness for some extensions of the pure logic of necessitation

A Model of Reasoning about Knowledge

The Finite Model Property of Some Non-normal Modal Logics with the Transitivity Axiom

On the local consequence of modal Product logic: standard completeness and decidability

Axiomatizing modal inclusion logic and its variants

Incompleteness of boundedly axiomatizable theories

The Logic of Correct Models

Kripke-Completeness and Sequent Calculus for Quasi-Boolean Modal Logic

Completeness of two fragments of a logic for conditional strategic reasoning

The finite frame property of some extensions of the pure logic of necessitation

The Lattice of Sahlqvist Logics

An $ω$-rule for the logic of provability and its models

Constructing Fully Complete Models of Multiplicative Linear Logic

Correspondence, Canonicity, and Model Theory for Monotonic Modal Logics