Abstract:An empirical question of long-standing interest is how price promotions affect a brand's sale shares in the fast-moving consumer-goods market. We investigated this question with concurrent promotions and sales records of specialty beer brands pooled over Tesco stores in the UK. Most brands were continuously promoted, rendering infeasible a conventional approach of establishing impact against an off-promotion sales baseline, and arguing in favor of a dynamics approach. Moreover, promotion/sales records were volatile without easily-discernable regularity. Past work conventionally attributed volatility to the impact of exogenous random shocks on stable markets, and reasoned that promotions have only an ephemeral impact on sales shares in stationary mean-reverting stochastic markets, or a persistent freely-wandering impact in nonstationary markets. We applied new empirical methods from the applied sciences to uncover an overlooked alternative: 'systematic persistence' in which promotional impacts evolve systematically in an endogenously-unstable market governed by deterministic-nonlinear dynamics. We reconstructed real-world market dynamics from the Tesco dataset, and detected deterministic-nonlinear market dynamics. We used reconstructed market dynamics to identify a complex network of systematic interactions between promotions and sales shares among competing brands, and quantified/characterized the dynamics of these interactions. For the majority of weeks in the study, we found that: (1) A brand's promotions drove down own sales shares (a possibility recognized in the literature), but 'cannibalized' sales shares of competing brands (perhaps explaining why brands were promoted despite a negative marginal impact on own sales shares); and (2) Competitive interactions between brands owned by the same multinational brewery differed from those with outside brands. In particular, brands owned by the same brewery enjoyed a 'mutually-beneficial' relationship in which an incremental increase in the sales share of one marginally increased the sales share of the other. Alternatively, the sales shares of brands owned by different breweries preyed on each other's market shares.

Hysteresis in Market Response: when is Marketing Spending an Investment?

Performance Growth and Opportunistic Marketing Spending

Economic Hysteresis and Its Mathematical Modeling

The Long-Term Effect of Marketing Strategy on Brand Sales

Estimating Marketing Persistence on Sales of Consumer Durables in China

Economic hysteresis in hog production

Investment Hysteresis: An Empirical Essay Turkish Case

Joint Dynamic Pricing and Marketing-Mix Strategies for Revenue Management Applications with Stochastic Demand

Targeting customers under response-dependent costs

Marketing Budget Allocation Across Countries: The Role of International Business Cycles

Hysteresis and Business Cycles

Hysteresis and the long shadow of the exchange rate regime

Reconstructing systematic persistent impacts of promotional marketing with empirical nonlinear dynamics

Your MMM is Broken: Identification of Nonlinear and Time-varying Effects in Marketing Mix Models

A Joint Dynamic Pricing and Multi-Channel Advertising Model with Stochastic Demand

Exploring Enterprise Marketing Investment Elasticity Based on Equilibrium Movement Model

Should Firms Spend More on Research and Development and Advertising during Recessions?

Dynamic Optimal Budget Allocation For Integrated Marketing Considering Persistence

Hysteresis Can Grant Fitness in Stochastically Varying Environment

Getting the most out of all your customers

Market Situation Interpretation and Response: The Role of Cognitive Style, Organizational Culture, and Information Use