Abstract:Background and objectives: While optical imaging is a useful technique to quantitate morphological differences and treatment effects, comparative investigations of the various techniques are lacking. This study aimed at evaluating intermethod agreement, reliability, and technical limitations of wide-field microscopy (WFM), reflectance confocal microscopy (RCM), and optical coherence tomography (OCT) for morphometry by assessing fractionally ablated nail tissue. Study design/materials and methods: Fifty healthy nail clippings were processed with a fractionated CO2 -laser (20 mJ/microbeam, density 15%), measured with calipers, and imaged using WFM, OCT, and RCM. Images were assessed for nail plate thickness, micropore dimensions, degree of poration, and artifacts. Repeated measurements (2-5) were taken to evaluate method repeatability using Cronbach's α and coefficients of variation (CoV), and estimate the intermethod correlation through linear correlation assessment (Pearson correlation coefficient [PCC]), ranked correlation (Kendall's tau; tau-c), and intraclass correlation (Shrout-Fleiss reliability coefficient; ICC). Results: The repeatability varied substantially between methods and target measurements. The level of intermethod agreement for thickness measurements performed with calipers, WFM, and OCT was high (tau-c ≥ 0.7; ICC ≥ 0.8; PCC ≥ 0.9). RCM could only image 28 out of 50 samples due to its limited penetration depth. OCT demonstrated the highest repeatability of all imaging techniques (CoV 4-7%) and nail thickness showed the highest measurement reliability (α = 0.92). Micropore dimensions correlated strongest between OCT and RCM (tau-c/ICC/PCC ≥ 0.5). All modalities were prone to artifacts, which may have adversely affected measurement variation and intermethod agreement. Conclusion: Intermethod agreement and reliability appear to be highly dependent on the specific modality and target measurement. To reap the benefits of each technique while mitigating their limitations, an integrated approach to optical imaging is recommended. Lasers Surg. Med. © 2020 Wiley Periodicals LLC.

Hydration of Fingernail Investigated by Optical Coherence Tomography

Instrumentation of Fiber-Based Functional Optical Coherence Tomographic Imaging System

Thin, Millimeter Scale Fingernail Sensors for Thermal Characterization of Nail Bed Tissue

High-resolution in vivo imaging of human nailbed microvasculature by using photoacoustic microscopy.

Optical Coherence Tomography in Fingertip Biometrics

A preliminary study of post-progressive nail-art effects on in vivo nail plate using optical coherence tomography-based intensity profiling assessment

In Vivo Structural and Functional Imaging of Human Nailbed Microvasculature Using Photoacoustic Microscopy.

Morphometric Optical Imaging of Microporated Nail Tissue: An Investigation of Intermethod Agreement, Reliability, and Technical Limitations

Nanomechanical characterization of human fingernail using nanoindentation and AFM

Opto-Thermal Transient Emission Radiometry (OTTER) to Image Diffusion in Nails in Vivo

Detection on Toe Nailfold Microcirculation of Healthy People

Structural Imaging of Benign Conjunctival Proliferative Diseases Using Optical Coherence Tomography

External and Internal Fingerprint Extraction Based on Optical Coherence Tomography

Influence of optical clearing agents on the scattering properties of human nail bed and blood microrheological properties: In vivo and in vitro study

Multiparametric Quantitative Analysis of Photodamage to Skin Using Optical Coherence Tomography

Influence of tooth-surface hydration conditions on optical coherence-tomography imaging

Quantitative Analysis on Tongue Inspection in Traditional Chinese Medicine Using Optical Coherence Tomography.

Medical diagnosis research using optical coherence tomography

Application of Optical Coherence Tomography in Nacre Identification and Characterization

Long-term Effect of High Intensity Physical Labor by Hand on Nailfold Microcirculation

Using Optical Coherence Tomography to Monitor Process of Wound Healing: a Preliminary Study